Karnataka High Court
Smt R B Basamma vs State Of Karnataka on 28 January, 2011
Author: B.V.Nagarathna
Bench: B.V.Nagarathna
IN mg: m<:,;I~1 COURT 0;? E{A.RNA"I'AKA AT BAN'G.iXLQ§<1E2
x:>m':3r) THIS T;---11;: 287" 139:5 01%' JANUARY. 20.'
V. B£~;"3¥<'ORI:3 K 3
m1«: HON*1';3I-f€ §\z'ERS.JUS'I°'ICIé1 _iF-3...V,._1\EAG27{R{5{f'fr§Z?-EEK'
WRIT PI3'£'I'£'ION No,4947/;::a1;3_"g;2x-£sn,&x:_.
BETWEEN I
SM? R. B. BASAMMA
AGED ABOUT 75 Y£:ARs----.._ .
19/ O SMT LATE I3ARV'AT'I--EAIVIMA---. 9
w/0 i;A'{'E; SHRI H.R.s1A1A.NKA--§2A;Ai..:I ' '
R/A'.I'NO.640/A.'.i6TI-fCROSS: _ _ :
6THPHASIE,L}.};iN£7f§C3A£{ " "
EBANGALORESBQ
{SENIOR CITIZPZNNG'f\1',AI~M'Eii;I"FOR PRJBJSENT)
_ _ -- .'.PETi'£'IONER
{By Sri: &{AR:T31%-i.AM;zgNA.v-G'1::.:\:;;;A3,,,' AIDV.)
é_1M.NQ.= .
» 1, QF
. "r-J
" ._ URBAN DE£VE3L0I3MF3N'T DEPARTMENT
' ';»a..s;.BU1:.m'NG, DR.A.M}":3EDKAR VEI§I).HI
=.E3ANvG}xI,ORE?¢'56O 001
. BY ITS :is.}j:::<::Ti~u«';'1'ARY
'r1L-ms: 1F3A. '\$GAE,ORf:1 I)1%:x:*:«:14,oI>MI«:m' A[.I".I'}-iORI'.I'Y
A 7£'.C1-*i*€3'W1)1X1AI**I RA013
x. ' MJMARA. PARK (W1 BANGA1-0RfEZ~56O 020
= .533'! ms COM"MISSi€)P~IER
THE Sf'E33C1AI,IJAl'\I'I) A{fQ{}L{SI'¥'IOE'€ oirrrlcm
BANGALOEEEZ if) f:§\? %Ef,,-CJPM f.iiN""I' ;"-¥£}"£'H{}f{I'["'¥'
.E3E§E*{ 5"E"'E-"I E3'?"fE'18E%Z, .E3z%.g';'~§'CEzX.L{:3f¥Z'%§Z;
, ., RESP€}f'€E} §%§1'£'T'S
LN
{I-3}; Sriii I-'i.'I".ARE€ND.P3A E"-'RAS;'\D, HCGP FOR R1.
S.RI'.K.F{.RI'SI"fNAK :"--\.If)V. FOR R2 ANI) R3]
"mus WP ES m,E;J:3 UNIDESR ARTICLES 2:25 k
Of' '1*m': CONSTITLWION or? H\II_)iA I>mx«*r:~:;: .. 532:)' 'g;;>,UAs;::
"ma ANNIEXUREZS vI;a:., .PR£2r_,1MIN;aRY NQ':'I'FJcAT--I.0N"'.
m'.7.11.o.2, ANN~L & FINAI. NQ2' i"-ICA'1'i'QN--. '1)'1*;':i;'9,O:<:{
PU'E3LESHI:ZI) IN GAZ£<1'I"f'E ON 10.9.'Q.3"A;NNwN _:g;"AtJc'r:oN
SALE NOTICE ANN--R.
TE-{IS PE"i'I'i"ION' COMING" PR151;IMINAR&'
HEARING IN *3' GROUP 3"IfHf:;~3_ ;:>;«i:.Y]'« j(_;--QvU»R_fr MADE T}~I}%2
FOLLOWING:- " '
In .y"::.1_I"1"i':~.\?$.'VI.':';.t ;5éi;;Etioi':--,.»ihe péfn'j'1f>Vner has c?ha1I.e11ged the
p1'e1i11'1i1'1éx:ytic:t,'ifi(fa.i'{i'{aL;;j 1 I /12002 {Annexure '{3} and
final I1ot,ific>§it:iQ.f1 vdaicyd '£3«,.I,':'2003 {Amxexure W') and auC'{.1'or1
_._sa1.e "i'O./v9_,_{.'?:OO3 {Annexure 'R? and has soughi
'~._a..ci'ire§:t.i<1n"to*r:dn5ider her repre.sem.ati0:1 and pass orders in
E1(£§?C)i'E§_§1'I1(_§E:' {._:::.m';1:m;.
.2. " VI{f1.:.<s the zjase of the: ;)et:%i'.ic):"1€:1' that. she is the ow1'1e.1'
, p'€§'s$ess;i(;:'1 01' Ianci beza.1*i:'1g Sy,N<}.I4/IA of
__"'Riagiilt,1va.r1.2:11a..11i, i;fti:e>.1'a.1";21Eii }4'i()bE%.§ Bz;1.:ig.gz;1E<)1"::~. South 'I'z1§:.1k,
u';'2':::é22:§2,,;1."%':':g§ 2. jkifféffi 29 C}£.1i.'1féZiS zmzzi €,E":ai. fizft :-asaitii ia.n£i *«.v2~1,<.-:;
mistifééézi 5:33: 2'.1<::q2.2i:+:§£i:i2;"t. fez' the pm'_p:}sc sf' f%>r*1<1'm};_; fur:'§2£%1"
€T*};§€fI1_é5i€)E} zzzzf' ESSK ES?" E-3'E1.:2zsse: @123?' i..§1<;% sseziéd Ii';§..I'iCifé5 wijtre irmizaiiy
T/Xv
puzmrhaeed by the pe'1.itio1'1e.:"'s r11c>1':i"1e:' E3}: at re;,gisie1'ec.i. sale
deed dzzieci 1 }/10/ E982 2::.1'1d on the death 91' the ;3e_'t.'i{'§i:ij';1e'1if;s
rmather on 9/8/1990. the pet.i.i.:ior1er has s1.1ec7.eedr3e1"if)'
said lands. when t.§1e malier st.:3c;(f§_i}ms, _-- ;i1'9e.'1'i;:?_1':1':1é;':*y"'arid V
firlal noi:ifieat.ions were issuea:1 for é2:ec;y{i':si:.'a*;io1'i».:)i'~the faint}
qziestion and the said t;c)i,ifi(>':iI','§«r)_:1s3 were eha1iiVe'ziVg;};<::*;i_Veb3r1 the --. L
pe::it.£0r1er in W.P.N<>.4653/ of by
Ethis C0111'? by order 8/?;_§§j8-..§=s1e{:{i:~{§I1r1eX:.tre 'P' and
the petitioner was E10 make a
represent:;1i.i0r1%_ ;}.he5 au1%10.rit:'Ees for
ef judgnlent passed by
t:.h:'$ and eonnee1,ec:i m21t1',e1*s,
dis;)0seei~.tV):f"--o2V1 the CifC',"i,'i£§1SI,8.11C€S, the
Cg)
pet1'1Iio_ne1' hziés sE)ucfh;-i, the. éi f0remer1Li0ned reliefs.
3.': 11;{xze heard the leamed eourasel for {he petitioner
L§:r1r::1"_{}1e'vIea;;rz'1;ed"'c:(>L1z1se1 for respcixrlcienfis. counsel for the
13ei.iifi()11e..__h @<_=.1,:.'brnif:s that the :*epreser1t.at.'E01'1 made by the
"'p€j:1'.ii,i0I1e:s " has 1'3()'1'i been ecmsidereci by the resp(>nden't
_ aLV1.'i*hr:-:"1't,ie;s:z zmci E.heref(::re the cIireet.ic):a. ggranied earlier by this
.. _,£§(?i1Fi. has not been céomplied with zimci iherefbre the
V peE.§.'£..i»:mer* emiziireéi is {he przzjgeres Inacie in {hie w':*it g::e;?£,§i.imL
Q"
6. It no cioubiz €111.16: i.112.1i'. ihif pe£'ii,i<)::'.:t31* has 11:)-£__fi.i<:c}
his 1'epr<%:3€r3'11a{'.i:):155 w'it'hi:1 the Limezzr p1"esC-ribed by .tfj:Q£i:j1
in t.I?'1€ a.i'<)1*eme1'1%.jonezd c)rcie21'. I:'i()w'€\=*€.1'._ {.118 c:c31'1F3;.§i§;*11'.ic)J§.'
iearxxeci c:o1,1nsei for re.spond€:1'1t, ~ z»1._ui:A.P1o_;"i'{ie:;é i',11.%:€'. El§'§f?,'l"f'3f is
no Such 1'ep1'€%$€n.ta1£ioI1 \,vhi(:h has b<.: i:11Fi1€d "iii i:e1'1?%ii~s 1c}f:
AI'1ne:-Xures 'Q-1' and 'Q42'. "U'1'"1--d.er '{.h'e Ci17C"LIZII':StaV1I'€;?€Sg':316*
po':i.ii'.i0n6r is ciirected to 1't11'I1is__fi'-..t;he_» acki1i)w1edgfineiiai, for
.112wiz1gg fiied the said 11%;)1§Cs¢:;t.a'§_iQ1'iS~émcéAif that is so. {ha
responcier1t:s W £1L!.f_.h()]'iil'('..i~3HEEICdi'1"€Ct.<3'd 1.()z(i::O'IiSiCi€l' the same
w1't:hi1'1 a pariah! c)E3T'%iv;'¢).V1'D.c)11;i;}V1s IfrV()n1"i.§ié"'dat:e of 1'ec:eip'I. of 21
cert.ii'ie;f (§(V)f)yV ;§)_1' .(')'1."s.73'£_':,'l", in of the order dated
8/8/2Ov"Q6:f}'&1SL~CVd iii}.incMVve:zji€ __pe{i.1.i011 filed by the pe'i1't',ioner herseif. 1*121sVé.¥_:)V<ét:'1i':I iE3;3c)sed of following the judgmem in \A'.§lP.vNi5.449¥i'9 in the ex-*e11't'. the pei:i1.io11@1" is unable ion,131*ociAm;c:, éhe said a<::know1edgnu:tI1t:. the pet;i1,j0uer is A'"}3€éi"'i.}'1i1,I,€{'1 'it) '.K'fti}:I1iSh oniy An;1ex:,11'r:3: Q and Q1 to the F~Z<3ss'p._c)r1Cvit%:';:iV.-'~:é:.L1t'.I'1()1'itics. Whc) shail c30r1sider "£118 sauna in V"':}§?C§()}"dEi'.i1(3€ with Law. if the said d()(?11I11ent.s have: been indeed "1}Cf:EI'u1"".S£1§3I3'Tfll§,€d by the p::=,{,i.1.ie:.me.:* to i,h.::* I'€?Sf}{}t1d€ITi', 2;:;%_;21i'1<>I'iiL:§<'i%ss=. are 22 pgzrt {sf Em: .2"t'3.*{?(,'}2'd§-'5 0%" 's.}1r'3 :"e§;g:3c:>z"2€1en.£, ' I ' . 21:L,:E.h<:sri'£y. '
7. With thtjé E}.b()V-'ET diI.'e(:i.i0r1s, the. wriif ;3e21;i.1_,is:3z: is ciEe3p(:$e<i of.
3% .~W"W " ;.:%?;§ , ma} Np ' W *m.vs