Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

4. The learned counsel, in support of his contention, makes reliance upon the following Judgments:-

i.T.Meer Ismail ali Vs. The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, reported in 2004 (3) CTC 120;

ii. B.Arun Kumar Vs. Secretary to the Government of Tamil Nadu, reported in 2011 (8) MLJ 457;

iii.C.Dilli Babu Vs. State of Tamil Nadu, reported in 2011 (7) MLJ 420; iv.N.Komalavathi Vs. Director of Elementary Education, reported in 2013 (70 MLJ 653;

v. S.Preethi Vs.The Commissioner, Land Survey and Land Revenue Department, [W.P.No.11601 of 2012, dated 22.11.2013]

10. In the decision in N.Komalavathi Vs. Director of Elementary Education, reported in 2013 (7 MLJ 653, this Court, after considering Government letter, dated 08.10.2007, has held as follows:

"7. As stated supra, the right to apply for compassionate appointment accrued to the petitioner only after finalization of the civil suit, on 27.08.1997. The date of death of petitioner's father being prior to 26.06.1995 as per Government Order issued in G.O.Ms.No.120, dated 26.06.1995, as clarified by letter of the Labour and Employment Department No.39924/Q1/95-1, dated 11.10.1995, three year period cannot be applied to the persons died prior to 26.06.1995. Without considering the said clarification issued by the Government and other relevant facts in this case, the impugned order was passed by the second respondent.

14. In yet another decision, a Division Bench of this Court in P.Sathiaraman v. Secretary to Government reported in (2013) 8 MLJ 190, after analyzing various Apex Court Judgments, has held as follows:

"7. We have carefully considered the rival submissions of either counsel and perused the materials available on record and the impugned order of the learned Single Judge.
8. In T.Meer Ismail Ali v.The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Chennai, 2004 (3) CTC 120 : LNIND 2004 MAD 57 : (2004) 4 MLJ 238, this Court held as under:-