Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

(4)   Discussion on expert opinions:

This commission received opinion dated 30.11.2015 from AIIMS. Thereafter, vide order dated 04.02.2016 the learned counsel for complainant was allowed to file interrogatories to the medical board. The commission received the replies from the AIIMS medical board on 29.03.2016. Similarly, complainant filed expert opinion from Prof Dr. Roger Williams and replies thereof to the interrogatories answered by Dr. Roger Williams.  
On careful perusal of expert opinion of Dr. Roger Williams and his replies to the respective interrogatories thereto, we are not convinced about the medical negligence. It is pertinent to note that the incidence was happened in year 1999 and at Meerut. The reasonability of treatment depends upon the circumstances like place/ facilities available in 1999 at Meerut. Dr Roger Williams never had experience of the medical practice in the Indian scenario. We are surprised to note in his conclusion mentioned that: