Document Fragment View
Fragment Information
Showing contexts for: SONEPAT in Mahender Singh vs State Of Haryana & Ors on 15 January, 2015Matching Fragments
24. On the application submitted by respondent No. 5, there is note by the Scrutinising Officer "not experience sic." In column No. 12 of the application, the following information was furnished:
"12. Experience: Years [04] Months [04] Days [17 ] Name of Organization - Sonepat Cheritable Eye Total Salary: Rs. 5000/-"
25. There is a communication dated 31.10.2007 by the Commission addressed to respondent No. 5 on record providing reason for non-fulfilment of condition of experience for rejection of her application. Thereafter, an undated request letter from respondent No. 5 to the Secretary of the Commission is on record requesting for issuance of roll number stating that she had submitted an application in pursuance to advertisement No. 9/2007. On that application, a note dated 15.11.2007 has been put by some official that "the applicant has removed the objection, hence, eligible". The file only contains the undated experience certificate from Sonepat Cheritable Eye Hospital, as was mentioned in the application form. From the certificate, it could not be opined as to for how much period respondent No. 5 may have worked with the hospital. As per communication dated 19.6.2008, the experience certificate produced by respondent No. 5 was found to be bogus as the authority verifying the same found that though her name was mentioned in the attendance register but the same has not been verified by any one. Neither any ledger was maintained nor income-tax returns were being filed. Still, vide letter dated 31.7.2008, respondent No. 5 was offered appointment as Family Welfare Extension Educator and consequently she joined service as such. In the file, there is a note dated 18.8.2009 from the office of Chief Minister desiring that respondent No. 5 may be transferred from CHC, Balla (Karnal) to CHC, Juan (Sonepat) against vacancy, which is extracted below:
"CM has desired that Smt. Anita Kumari, Health Educator, Health Deptt., CHC Balla (Karnal) may be transferred to CHC Juan (Sonepat) against vacancy."
26. There is another note dated 20.8.2009 from the office of Chief Minister desiring that respondent No. 5 may be transferred from CHC Ballah (Karnal) to CHC, Jaun (Sonepat) vice Sh. Jitender Singh and vice versa, which is extracted below:
"12. Experience: Years [2] Months [1] Days [- ] Name of Organization - Dr. A.V. Baliga Memorial Trust Total Salary: Voluntary"
28. The file contained another experience certificate dated 10.8.2007 from Double S. Youth Club (Regd.), Delhi showing that respondent No. 6 worked with the Club as Social Worker for community education in health and family welfare from 10.2.2005 to 31.3.2007 on a monthly honorarium of ` 1,500/-. The aforesaid certificate was sent for verification. As per the report from Civil Surgeon, Sonepat vide communication dated 19.6.2008 addressed to Director General, Health Services Haryana, Panchkula, the aforesaid certificate was found to be fake, as it was found that there was neither any ledger maintained by the Club nor income-tax return was being filed and there was no record with the Club pertaining to the certificate, though the certificate contained serial number. Despite this verification report from Civil Surgeon, Sonepat, respondent No. 6 was issued appointment letter on 6.8.2008 and he joined his service on 9.8.2008. He was directed to join at PHC, Ladwa (Kurukshetra).
29. The case of respondent No. 6 is also similar to respondents No. 4 and 5 if considered in the light of their access to the corridors of power. There is a note dated 17.5.2013 from the office of Chief Minister desiring that respondent No. 6 be transferred from CHC, Pehowa (Kurukshetra) to CHC, Mudlana (Sonepat). There is a letter dated 5.7.2013 from Dr. Arvind Sharma, Member of Parliament (Lok Sabha), Karnal to Director General, Health Services Haryana for deputing respondent No. 6 from CHC, Pehowa (Kurukshetra) to CHC, Firozpur Bangar (Sonepat) for 60 days. The order was complied with on 10/15.7.2013. There is another note from Jaiveer Singh, CPS, Haryana Government to Director General, Health Services Haryana dated 27.9.2013 that respondent No. 6 working at CHC, Pehowa, District Kurukshetra may be deputed to CHC, Firozpur Bangar, District Sonepat. On account of different recommendations made by the authorities pertaining to certain employees, the matter was sent to Chief Minister's office again and in terms of the directions of the Chief Minister, respondent No. 6 was transferred from CHC, Pehowa to CHC, Nissing (Karnal), as is evident from the office note dated 14.11.2013. The transfer order is dated 18.11.2013. The note dated 22.10.2013 from the office of Chief Minister, available in support of the aforesaid noting in the file, is extracted below: