Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

29. It was also argued that Ext. PW2/A complaint of PW2 has been tampered with. According to the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant/accused, the testimony of PW2 shows that that the latter is unaware of the contents of Ext. PW2/A complaint because while examined he deposed that he had not signed Ext. PW2/A complaint after reading the same and that the complaint had not been lodged in the presence of PW8. PW2 claimed that he had in fact mentioned the name of Paltu Ram in his complaint. PW2 also claimed that the police had obtained his signature on blank papers. Therefore, referring to this part of the testimony of PW2, the argument advanced is that that it is a clear case of tampering of Ext. PW2/A complaint, which aspect alone is sufficient to throw out the entire prosecution case. This argument also at first blush appeared quite appealing. But a closer scrutiny of the materials on record show that the argument is also not correct. PW8, the independent panch witness, deposed that the complaint of PW2, that is, Ext. PW2/A had been recorded by PW9 in his presence, at which time PW2 was also present. PW8 also deposed that he had affixed his signature in Ext. PW2/A complaint and PW8, while in the box, identified his signature at point 'B' in Ext. PW2/A complaint. This aspect of the testimony is corroborated by the testimony of PW9, the TLO, deposed that on 03.04.2000, he had recorded Ext.PW2/A complaint of PW2 in the presence of PW8. PW9 also deposed that the complaint was regarding the demand of bribe of ₹300/- by HC Sumer Singh (the accused) of Patel Nagar police station for returning the RC of the stolen motorcycle of PW2. The testimony of PW8 and PW9 on these aspects has not been discredited in any manner and, therefore, I find no reasons to disbelieve them. Their testimony will also show that PW2 was clearly resiling from his version in Ext. PW2/A complaint and therefore, the trial court was quite justified in initiating proceedings under Section 344 Cr.P.C against him.