Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

15.19 PW20 Sh. P.K. Gottam, Sr. Scientific Officer-I (Photo) CFSL, CBI, New Delhi has compared the photograph of accused Ramesh Chander (S-16) and Rajpal (S-19) with video file no.V0109001.AVI and came to the conclusion that the persons appearing in the sample photographs (S-16 & S-19) appeared to be similar with the person visible in the aforesaid video files. He also proved his report dated 12.5.2016 as Ex.PW-17/B (D-11).

15.20 PW21 Sh. Gautam Roy Retd. Sr. Scientific Officer and Head of the Department in the computer forensic and head of the department in the computer Forensic Division & Photo Division in CFSL CBI New Delhi examined the memory cards and micro SD cards Ex.6/1 to 6/5 and came to the conclusion that there was continuous flow of video and there was no stoppage, pause etc. and, therefore, there was no tampering on the aforesaid five memory cards. He proved his report as Ex.PW-21/A. (D) CBI OFFICIALS 15.21 PW17 Sanjay Upadhayay is the second IO of the case. He deposed that the initial investigation had been carried out by Inspector Kailash Sahu and he was handed over the investigation after Inspector Kailash Sahu was posted out from ACB branch. He deposed that most of the witnesses had already been examined by the previous IO and he recorded supplementary statements of some such witnesses and also recorded statements of few more witnesses. He further deposed that during the investigation 11 photographs Marked S-10 to S-20 were sent to CFSL for the purpose of comparison with the persons visible in the video files of the sting operation. The SD cards had already been sent to CFSL. He proved the forwarding letter along with annexures as Ex.PW-17/A. The report of Sh. P. K. Gottam, Sr. Scientific Officer was proved as Ex.PW-17/B. He also deposed that other reports were also received from CFSL and he had collected documents from MCD and Delhi Police. He received letter Mark PW-6/1 (D-20) from EE (Building) Najafgarh Zone in response to his letter Ex.PW-17/C (Part of D-20). He also collected certificate under Section 65-B from Chetan Prakash contained in D-13 which was seized vide memo Ex. PW-17/D (D-12). He further deposed that vide memo Ex.6/A (D-14) he had collected the posting/attendance details of MCD officials and the details have already been exhibited as Ex.PW-1/A to PW-1/D colly. (D-15). He also deposed that he had also received letter from EE M-III/NGZ dated 07.06.2016 along with appointment details of daily wages. The said letter along with its annexures was exhibited as Ex.PW-17/E (colly.) and all such documents were taken into possession vide memo Ex.PW-17/F. He also proved the statement of Rajinder Kumar Ex.PW- 12/A and Swarndeep Shukla Mark PW-15/B. He testified that sanction order Ex. PW-16/A was received from Sh. Sanjiv Kumar, the then Deputy Commissioner, Najafgarh Zone. After completion of investigation he filed the charge sheet.