Document Fragment View
Fragment Information
Showing contexts for: computer science in Puneet Sharma vs Himachal Pradesh State Electricity ... on 7 April, 2021Matching Fragments
“ASSISTANT ENGINEER (E) COL. 7 (Direct Recruitment) Minimum educational and other qualification required for direct recruits.
Existing Provisions Amended Provision
i) Recognized Degree in Electrical i) Regular/Full time Degree in
Engineering or electrical & Electronics Electrical Engineering or electrical &
Engineering from recognized Electronics Engineering from recognized
Institution/University duly recognized Institution/University duly approved by
by the Central/State Govt. for the AICTE or AMIE from Institution of
AE(E)posts. Engineers (India Calcutta) or Ex-
servicemen who have the relevant
ii) Recognized Degree in Computer equivalence to a recognized Degree in
Science Engineering or Electronic & above stream/ discipline recognized by
Communication Engineering or the Govt. of India for AE(E) posts.
Information technology OR its ii) Regular/Full time Degree in
equivalent from recognized by the Computer Science Engineering or
Central /State Govt. for AE (IT) post. Electronic & Communication
Engineering or Information technology
Desirable OR its equivalent from a recognized
(a) Experience of working in Institution/ University duly approved by
Design/Construction in hilly areas. the AICTE or AMIE in above stream/
(b) Knowledge of Customs, manners discipline recognized by the Govt. of
and dialects of Himachal Pradesh & India for AE (E) post.
Suitability for appointment in Peculiar Desirable
conditions prevailing in the state. (a) Experience of working in
Design/Construction in hilly areas.
(b) Knowledge of Customs, manners
and dialects of Himachal Pradesh &
Suitability for appointment in Peculiar
conditions prevailing in the state.
ASSISTANT ENGINEER (E)
Col. No. 11 (iii) (iv) & (v)
In case of recruitment by promotion, deputation, transfer, grades from which promotion/deputation/transfer is to be made.13
Existing Provision Amended Provisions
(iii) from amongst those persons who (iii) from amongst those persons who
pass/acquire the qualification of pass/acquire the qualification of AMIE
AMIE/Degree in Electrical (Section A & B) or who acquire Full time/
Engineering/ Electrical & Electronic Regular Degree in Electrical Engineering/
Engineering/ Computer Science Electrical &Electronic Engineering/
Engineering, Electronic & Computer Science Engineering. Electronics
Communication Engineering & & Communication Engineering &
Information Technology in Service Information Technology in service after
having minimum one year regular confirmation to service. = 5%
service after confirmation to service
= 6%
(iv) Drawing Staff: (iv) Drawing Staff:
Circle Head Draftsman possessing Circle Head Draftsman possessing Diploma
Diploma in Elect. Engineering or in Elect. Engineering or Diploma
Diploma Certificate of Draftsmanship Certificate of Draftsmanship from a
from a recognized Institute having 5 recognized Institute having 5 years’ service
years’ service in the grade failing which in the grade failing which 10 years’ service 10 years’ service as Draftsman/Head as Draftsman/Head Draughtsman/Circle Draughtsman/Circle Head Head Draughtsman and failing both total Draughtsman and failing both total 15 15 years services in the Draftsman cadre.
years services in the Draftsman cadre. = 4%
=3%
(v) Before joining the service as JE who (v) Before joining the services as JE who
possess degree in Electrical possess Regular/ Full time degree in
Engineering/ Electrical & Electronic Electrical Engineering/ Electrical &
Engineering/ Computer Science Electronic Engineering/ Computer Science
Engineering. Electronics & Engineering. Electronics & Communication
Communication Engineering & Engineering & Information Technology
Information Technology from a from a recognized university approved by
recognized university including AMIE the AICTE. Ex-servicemen who have the
& having minimum one year regular relevant qualification equivalence to a
service in the cadre of JE after recognized Degree in Electrical
confirmation in the service. =5% Engineering or Electrical & Electronic
Engineering Stream/ discipline recognized
by the Govt. of India or person who posses
AMIE qualification in above stream/
discipline from Institute or Engineers (India
Calcutta) after confirmation to service.
=5%
21. During pendency of the litigation, on 03.06.2020, the HPSEB further amended the Rules inserting a provision enabling candidates with a minimum matriculation with diploma in Computer Science Engineering or Electronic & Communication Engineering as well as those with degrees. The amendment reads as follows:
“Diploma or degree in Computer Science Engineering or ElectronicEngineering & Communication Engineering or Information Technology from recognised Institute/ University established by Law by the State/ Central Govt. OR AMIE from Institution of Engineers (India) (only those candidates who are enrolled for AMIE with the Institute of Engineers (India) Kolkata will be permanent recognition up to 3105.2013) would be eligible.” After taking into account the submission of the parties, the High Court by the impugned judgment, endorsed the opinion of the committee and was of the view that only those with matriculation and holding diploma in the relevant subject are 9 O.A. 7397 of 2018 10 By an order dated 21.05.2019 considered eligible for the post of Junior Engineer. In W.P (C) 1028/2020, the Petitioners argue that the notification of 03.06.2020 is arbitrary as it is prospective; in the alternative, they claim that it should be read as clarificatory and therefore always applicable.