Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

CBI Vs. M/s Kamal Sponge Steel & Power Ltd. & Ors., Judgement dated 19.05.2017 Page No. 39 of 350

49. In support of his submissions for A-1 M/s KSSPL and A-2 Pawan Kumar Ahluwalia Ld. Counsel Sh. Pavan Narang placed reliance upon the following case law: 

       S.                            Case Title                                    Citation
       No.
         1     Kali Ram Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh                       (1973)2 SCC 808
         2     Ashish Batham Vs. State of MP                                 (2002)7 SCC 317
         3     Kailash Gour and Ors.Vs. State of Assam                      (2012)2 SCC 34
         4     Sri Rabindra Kumar Dey Vs. State of Orissa (1976)4 SCC 233
         5     Prem Kumar Gulati and Anr. Vs. State of (2014)14 SCC 646
               Haryana
         6     L.K. Advani Vs. CBI                                          1997 CrLJ 2559
         7     Nabi Mohamad Chand Hussain and Ors. Vs. 1980 CrLJ 860
               State of Maharashtra
         8     State of Kerala Vs. P. Sugathan & Anr.                       (2000)8 SCC 203
         9     Sharad Birdhichand Sarda Vs. State of (1984) 4 SCC 116
               Maharashtra
        10 Hanumant Vs State of MP                                          1952 SCR 1091
         11 C. Chenga Reddy Vs. State of A.P                                (1996) 10 SCC

54. In the aforesaid circumstances it was submitted by Ld. CBI Vs. M/s Kamal Sponge Steel & Power Ltd. & Ors., Judgement dated 19.05.2017 Page No. 44 of 350 Counsel Sh.Sushil Bajaj that in the absence of there being any legally admissible evidence against A-3 Amit Goyal it is crystal clear that prosecution has miserably failed in proving its case against him.

55. In support of his submissions Ld. Counsel Sh. Sushil Bajaj placed reliance upon the following case law: 

 S.                            Case Title                                  Citation
         No.
           1    Kali Ram Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh                      (1973)2 SCC 808
           2    Ashish Batham Vs. State of MP                               (2002)7 SCC 317
           3    Kailash Gour and Ors.Vs. State of Assam                     (2012)2 SCC 34
           4    Sri Rabindra Kumar Dey Vs. State of Orissa (1976)4 SCC 233
           5    Prem Kumar Gulati and Anr. Vs. State of (2014)14 SCC 646
                Haryana
           6    L.K. Advani Vs. CBI                                         1997 CrLJ 2559
           7    Nabi Mohamad Chand Hussain and Ors. 1980 CrLJ 860
                Vs. State of Maharashtra
           8    State of Kerala Vs. P. Sugathan & Anr.                      (2000)8 SCC 203


        A-3 Amit Goyal was thus prayed to be acquitted.

Arguments on behalf of A-4 H.C. Gupta