Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

6. PW1 has further deposed that plaintiff no.1 adopted the trademark "BAILLEY" in the year 1992 for its packaged drinking water and has been using the said trademark extensively and continuously since then. The plaintiff no.2 merged with the plaintiff no.1 with effect from November 1, 2003 and since then became a unit of plaintiff no.1. Over the years the trademark "BAILLEY" has gained immense popularity and goodwill and people relate and associate the said trademark with the plaintiff no.1 company. The Amalgamation Order of Parle Agro Pvt. Ltd. 

       Sl.        Trade Mark     Trade          Class Date      of Status
       No.                       Mark                 registration
                                 No.
       1.         PARLE BAILEY 584190             32     05.11.1992      Registered
                  (Label)
       2.         PARLE          621903           32     15.03.1994      Registered
                  BAILLEY
                  AQUA (label)
       3.         BAILLEY        647221           32     30.11.1994      Registered
                  AQUA
       4.         PARLE          749335           32     30.07.1997      Registered
                  BAILLEY
                  MINERAL
                  WATER (label)
       5.         PARLE          749336           32     30.07.1997      Registered
                  BAILLEY (word)
       6.         PARLE          749338           29     30.07.1997      Registered
                  BAILLEY(word)
       7.         PARLE          767884           32     08.10.1997      Registered
                  BAILLEY SODA
                  (label)
       8.         PARLE          1001757          32     09.04.2001      Registered
                  BAILLEY
                  AQUA (label)
       9.         PARLE          1119236          32     16.07.2002      Registered
                  BAILLEY
                  AQUA (label)
       10.        BAILLEY        1538518          32     16.07.2002      Registered
                  NATURALE

                   (label)
       11.        BAILLEY        1538520         32     09.03.2007       Registered
                  NATURALE
                  (word)
       12.        PARLE AGRO 1654182             32     15.02.2008       Registered
                  BAILLEY (word)
       13.        BAILLEY (word) 1654181         32     15.02.2008       Registered

The certificates for legal proceedings with respect to each of the above mentioned trademarks have been exhibited as Ex.PW1/5(colly).

8. It has also been deposed that the trademark "BAILLEY" and its variants have been filed by the plaintiff no.1 and the same are pending: 

       Sl.        Trade Mark     Trade           Class Date       of Status
       No.                       Mark No.              registration
       1.         BAILLEY SODA 2120824           32    24.03.2011    Pending
                  (label)
       2.         BAILLEY SODA 1643086           32      18.01.2008       Opposed
                  WITH RIBBON
                  (label)
       3.         BAILLEY WITH 2561764           32      09.07.2013       Pending
                  PARLE AGRO
                  REFRESHING
                  INDIA (label)
       4.         BAILLEY (word) 2561766         32      09.07.2013       Pending
       5.         BAILLEY        2561767         32      09.07.2013       Pending
                  NATURAL
                  MINERAL
                  WATER
       6.         BAILLEY (word) 2561771         16      09.07.2013       Pending

2011 till 8,576,042 3,558,865 12,304,545 14,765 oct.

TOTAL 32,913,684 12,029,330 47,564,382 52,765 Institutional sales figures of the plaintiff‟s product "BAILLEY" for the last eight years: 

            Year               Quantity sold      Value of          Advertisement
                               by pale agro       Quantity sold     Expense by
                               pvt. Ltd.          (Rs. In lakhs)    Parle Agro Pvt.
                               (cartoons/Jar)                       Ltd. (Rs. In

                                                                 lakhs)
            2003-04        3,163,506          1,119,62          7.21
            2004-05        3,109,346          1,290,50          1.39
            2005-06        3,297,368          1,588,77          22.26
            2006-07        1,657,162          1,103,47          12.29
            2007-08        597,776            397,53            43.89
            2008-09        279,202            146,52            42.25
            2009-10        92,872             81.00             14.36
            2010-11        114,844            105.56            16.62
            TOTAL          12,312,036         5832.97           160.26