Document Fragment View
Fragment Information
Showing contexts for: Problems in Shafiq Ahmad vs Uttarakhand Transport Corporation on 10 November, 2023Matching Fragments
6)
2. WPSS No. Driver 29.07.2015 Medical Board Not clear. Other office 2174 of 2022, Report; Eye Problem related work;
Suresh Kumar Post traumatic since 2015 Vs. optic atrophy in Uttarakhand right eye with Transport complete loss in Corporation right eye. He is through its unfit to drive Managing (Annexure 5 Director and Disability others Certificate)
3. WPSS No. Driver 12.05.2021 Medical Board Not clear. Other official 2179 of 2022, Report; Unfit to Intestine work;
Harshmohan heavy duty and Cancer Vs. driving Uttarakhand (Annexure 5) Transport Corporation through its Managing Director Dehradun and others 4. WPSS No. Conductor 05.08.2017 Medical Board Not clear. Other office 2180 of 2022, Report; Right Visually related work; Lal Singh Vs. Eye Central handicapped- Group D Uttarakhand Opacity with 40% Transport Left Eye Corporation Eviscerated with Through its no perception of Managing Light. He is Director visually Dehradun and handicapped others 40% (Annexure 5) 5. WPSS No. Driver 22.03.2017 Medical Board Not clear. Other official 2182 of 2022 Report; Heart disease work Harish Kumar Angioplasty; Vs. Not fit for Uttarakhand driving; Transport (Annexure 5) Corporation through its Managing Director Dehradun and others 6. WPSS No. Driver 18.06.2014 Medical Board Not clear. Other 2184 of 2022, Report; Severe Eye problem Official Chandra Pal impairment of Work Singh Vs. vision of right Uttarakhand eye due to Transport coreo-retinel Corporation (Annexure 5) through its Managing Director, Dehradun and others 7. WPSS No. Driver 16.12.2001 Medical Board Not clear Other 2186 of 2022 Report; Post Official Maya Ram traumatic Work Bhatt Vs. atrophy of lower Uttarakhand limb; disability Transport 40%. Corporation (Annexure- 5) through its Managing Director Dehradun and others 8. WPSS No. Driver 2007 Due to accident On duty Clerk 2211 of 2022, sustained some Accident Phoola Singh injuries; In Vs. WPSS 995 of Uttarakhand 2008 on Transport 04.03.2011 Corporation direction given through its to assign other General work to the Manager and petitioner another 9. WPSS No. Driver 14.09.2019 Medical On duty Peon 2212 of 2022, Certificate; Dhan Singh Vs. Collar Bone The Secretary Fracture State Road (Annexure 2) Transport Corporation Uttarakhand and others 10. WPSS No. Conductor 01.10.2016 Medical Board On duty Other official 2258 of 2022, Report; work Subhash Cervical/ Chandra Lumbar Badola Vs. spondylitis Managing (Annexure 3) Director, Uttarakhand Transport Corporation and others 11. WPSS No. Driver 25.05.1995 Medical Board On duty Other 2259 of 2022, Report; Knee Official Jagmohan Vs. Injury Work Managing (Annexure 4) Director Uttarakhand Transport Corporation and others 12. WPSS No. Driver 19.10.1997 Medical Officer On duty Other official 2260 of 2022, Communication; work Rajendra Accidental Kumar Vs. Injury Managing (Annexure 4) Director Uttarakhand Transport Corporation and others 13. WPSS No. 2280 of 2022, Jagjeet Singh and others Vs. Uttarakhand Transport Corporation Dehradun and others (i) Jagjeet 1. Driver 2004 Concession On Duty; Other official Singh Certificate; While going work Right leg to depot; amputation; 80% Disability (Annexure 2) (ii) Satnam 2. Driver 2003 Medical Board On Duty Other official Singh Report; Hip work bone injury (Annexure 3) (iii) Sukhdev 3. Driver 2011 No document; On Duty Other official Singh Hip Fracture work 14. WPSS No. 2298 of 2022, Bhajan Singh and another Vs. Uttarakhand Transport Corporation Dehradun and others (i) Bhajan Driver 2022 Medical Board Not clear; Other official Singh Certificate; Hip Hip Injury work bone injury (ii) Anil Kumar Conductor 16.06.2021 Medical Board On duty Other official Mishra Certificate; accident; work AIDS Subsequently (Annexure 3), AIDS 15. WPSS No. Driver 2000 Medical Board On duty Other work 2306 of 2022, Certificate; Jitendra Singh Damaged vision Vs. Managing of left eye Director, (Annexure 5) Uttarakhand Transport Corporation Dehradun and others 16. WPSS No. Driver 16.01.2005 No Medical On duty; Other official 2315 of 2022, Report; Insect bite work Brij Lal Vs. Poisonous insect Managing cut on left eye; Director, Absence from Uttarakhand duty Transport Corporation Dehradun and others 17. WPSS No. Driver 17.07.2018 Medical Report; Not clear; Other official 2340 of 2022, FUC of Sleep apnea work Keshav Dutt obstructive Joshi Vs. Sleep apnea Uttarakhand (Annexure 5) Transport Corporation through its Managing Director Dehradun and others 18. WPSS No. Driver 09.12.2019 Medical Board Not clear; Other official 2344 of 2022 Report; AMT Vertigo work Munabbar Ali Vertigo and Vs. Poly Uttarakhand Neurological Transport Tremor Corporation Dehradun and another 19. WPSS No. Driver 2018 Heart attack; Not clear; Other official 2348 of 2022, Now fitness Now fit work Jai Pal Singh certificate to Vs. Managing join duties of Director driver for day Uttarakhand time only. Transport (Annexure 6 and Corporation 8) and others 20. WPSS No. Driver 15/16.08. Medical Board On duty; Other duty 2349 of 2022, 1998 Report; Ecliptic Injured Ram Surat Vs. fits during Uttarakhand dacoity Transport Corporation through its General Manager and another 21. WPSS No. Driver 2015 Medical Board Not clear; Other official 2353 of 2022, Report; Ecilepsy work Sanjeev Kumar Seizure disorder Vs. Managing (Annexure 5) Director Uttarakhand Transport Corporation and others 22. WPSS No. Driver 2008 Medical Board Not clear; Other official 2382 of 2022, Report; Eye problem work Mohan Lal Vs. Defective Managing Vision Director (Annexure 2) Uttarakhand Transport Corporation and another 23. WPSS No. 2386 of 2022, Rajendra Kumar Arya and another Vs. Uttarakhand Transport Corporation Dehradun and others (i) Rajendra Driver 2016 No medical On duty Other duties Kumar Arya certificate; Suffered injury in left leg due to accident and rod was fixed (ii) Jagmohan Driver 2015 Medical Board On duty Other duties Report; Slip Disc problem Medical Certificate, (Annexure 2) 24. WPSS No. Conductor 02.02.2018 Medical Board On duty Other official 2407 of 2022, Certificate/ work Bhagwan Singh Report; Brain Vs. Managing Haemorrhage Director Uttarakhand Medical Transport certificate Corporation (Annexure 4) and others 25. WPSS No. Driver 2021 Medical Board Not clear; Other official 2467 of 2022, Report; Cataract work Harjindar Cataract; Singh Vs. Medical Uttarakhand Certificate Transport (Annexure 3) Corporation Dehradun and another 26. WPSS No. Driver 28.07.2017 Medical Board On duty Other official 2469 of 2022, Report; work Charan Singh Old L1 Vs. Managing Vertiberal Director, Fracture without Uttarakhand Neurological Transport deficit; Corporation (Annexure 1) and others 27. WPSS No. Driver 2015 No medical Not clear; Other official 2476 of 2022, certificate; Back work Sirazuddin Vs. Back problem Problem Managing Director, Uttarakhand Transport Corporation and others 28. WPSS No. Driver 2015 A On duty; Retired on 2494 of 2022, communication Eye problem 21.12.2022 Daleep Kumar of Doctor; Sharma Vs. Eyesight blurred Uttarakhand Transport Corporation through its Managing Director and others 29. WPSS No. 3 of Driver 21.01.2018 Medical Board Not clear; Retired on 2023, Pitamber Report; Brain Brain 21.12.2022 Singh Vs. hemorrhage; Haemorrhage Uttarakhand ( Annexure 4) Transport Corporation through its Managing Director and others 30. WPSS No. 16 Driver 2018 Medical Board Not clear; Retired on of 2023, Vinod Report; Obesity 22.12.2022 Kumar Vs. Grade III Uttarakhand obesity Transport (Annexure 3) Corporation Dehradun and another 31. WPSS No. 67 Conductor 16.10.2019 Medical Board On duty; Retired on of 2023, Report; Leg fracture 22.12.2022 Gurumukh Fracture of both Singh Vs. bone left leg Managing with left ulna Director, (Annexure 2) Uttarakhand Transport Corporation and others 32. WPSS No. 68 Conductor 19.03.2014 Medical Board On duty; Retired on of 2023, Report; Heart 20.12.2022 Vishesh Kumar Diabetes with problem Vs. Managing coronary Director artillery /heart Uttarakhand problem Transport (Annexure 3) Corporation and others 33. WPSS No. 78 Conductor Injured on duty; On duty Retired on of 2023, Bhanu Now fitness 20.12.2022 Prakash Vs. certificate issued Managing (Annexure 2) Director Uttarakhand Transport Corporation and others 34. WPSS No. 86 Driver 17.04.2020 Medical Board Not clear; Retired on of 2023, Report; Heart disease 23.12.2022 Nagendra Medical Pratap Singh treatment of Vs. The heart Managing (Annexure 1) Director State Road Transport Corporation Uttarakhand and others 35. WPSS No. 87 Conductor 30.01.2022 Medical Board On duty; Retired on of 2023, Report; Seizure Cerebral fits 23.12.2022 Ravikant Disorder Shukla Vs. The (Annexure 3) Managing Director State Road Transport Corporation Uttarakhand and others 36 WPSS No. 88 Conductor 22.11.2021 Medical Board On duty Retired on of 2023, Ram Report; 23.12.2022 Asray Shukla Right Hip bone Vs. The Injury Managing (Annexure 2) Director State Road Transport Corporation Uttarakhand and others 37 WPSS No. 89 Conductor 2012 Chief Medical Not clear; Retired on of 2023, Satish Officer Spondylitis 26.12.2022 Kumar Vs. The Communication; Managing Cervical Director State Spondylitis Road Transport (Annexure 2) Corporation Uttarakhand and others, 38 WPSS No. 101 Conductor 14.07.2022 Medical Board On duty; Retired on of 2023, Alok Report; Head injury 23.12.2022 Williams Vs. Head Injury The Managing (Annexure 1); Director State Fitness Road Transport certificate issued Corporation (Annexure 5) Uttarakhand Dehradun and others 39. WPSS No. 102 Driver 2004 Medical Board Not clear; Retired on of 2023, Amod Report; Back 23.12.2022 Sharma Vs. Injury in problem The Managing backbone Director State (Annexure 2) Road Transport Corporation Uttarakhand and others 40 WPSS No. 146 Driver 2019 Medical Board Not clear; Retired on of 2023, He was Report; Cataract 10.01.2023 Surendra Singh declared fit Cataract; Vs. for duties Now fitness Uttarakhand later as Certificate Transport driver (Annexure 7) Corporation Dehradun and another 41. WPSS No. 147 Driver 2022 Medical Board Not clear; Retired on of 2023, Report; Cataract 10.01.2023 Malkeet Singh Cataract Vs. (Annexure 3); Uttarakhand Now fitness Transport Certificate Corporation issued Dehradun and (Annexure 9) another 42. WPSS No. 635 Driver 2018 Eye Deficiency; Not clear; Retired on of 2023, No medical Eye problem 23.12.2022 Jagdish Prasad certificate Vs. Managing Director Uttarakhand Transport Corporation and others
285.
20. For the purposes of classification between two groups of drivers/conductors, one who sustained injuries while on duty and second, who sustained injuries while off duty per se may not be held to be invalid. But, it requires further elaboration.33
21. All the petitioners are not the cases of incapacity due to accident. There are cases of weak eyesight, heart problem and other problems. Even for making such classifications, it was necessary to examine each case individually so as to ascertain as to how each of the petitioners become incapacitated to work on the post which he held. As to whether the incapacity is attributable or has been aggravated by the nature of duty? If the incapacity may be attributable or aggravated due to nature of the duty, its natural corollary would be that such incapacity would fall in the category of "incapacity arisen while on duty". This exercise has not been done. Therefore, the classification which the respondent no.1 the UTC has done is not complete.