Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

14. This Tribunal in O.A. No.3015/2013 and batch, dated 19.09.2014, examined identical issue under identical circumstances, in detail, while dismissing the O.As. observed as under:

6. In the present case, the RRs for the post in question provided Master Degree in the subject concerned from any recognized university as one of the essential qualification for being eligible for the post. Admittedly, there is no course like Master Degree in Biology. As has been ruled by Honble Supreme Court in the aforementioned case, it was beyond the jurisdiction of DSSSB to comment upon the eligibility of the candidates. In such circumstances, they admitted the candidates with Master Degree in Bio-Technology, Bio-Chemistry, Micro Biology and Genetics in the examination held for selection to the post of PGT (Biology). Nevertheless having due regard to the competence of the power of the State legislative and the Governor of the State, i.e. the Executive to frame the rules under Article 309 of the Constitution in the notice for selection as well also in the result notice they indicated that it was for the appointing authority to satisfy itself about the eligibility of the candidates as per RRs before finally appointing the candidates. In this regard, we may refer to column 9 (v) of Section C of the notice published vide advertisement no. 2/2010 and the relevant excerpt of result notice, which reads as under:-
Keeping in view of the above contradictory position, we may refer the following matters to the committee to be constituted for taking decision for the consideration of these cases for the appointment in subject concerned.
1. Candidates having educational qualification in Masters degree in Bio technology, Bio Chemistry, Micro-Biology and Genetics for the appointment of PGT (Biology).
2. Candidate having educational qualification in Masters Degree in Electronics for the appointment of PGT (Physics).

Submitted please.

Sd/-

O.S(E-II) A.D.E (E.II) Sd/-

ADDL. DE (Admn.) Sd/-

DE Secy (Edn) As a result of aforementioned decision, the following Committee was constituted to consider the case of the candidates having educational qualification of Master Degree in Bio-Technology, Micro-Biology, Bio Chemistry and Genetics regarding their appointment for the post of PGT (Biology): 

	 (1) Addl. DE (School)                                      ..Chairman
(2) One expert each in Biology/Physics/Home Science subject          from Delhi University to be nominated by the Vice Chancellor Delhi University                   ..Member
(3) One expert each in Biology/Physics/Home Science subject from SCERT			               .. Member
(4) An officer of the level of Principal/Vice Principal worked as PGT (Biology), Physics & Home Science to  be nominated by DDE (North)                                             .. Member
3. Sh.S.D.Sharma (Biology) Principal, RPVV Rajniwas Marg .. Member
4. Dr.Bandita B.Mohanty (Biology), Sr.Lecturer, DIET Keshav Puram .. Member The agenda of the meeting was discussed in details and the committee decided unanimously the following:-
1. The candidate for the post of PGT (Biology) must have M.Sc degree in Botany or Zoology as they can impart the basic concept in Biology clearly to teach the students at the Senior Secondary level.
2. As the candidates go higher in any specialized branch (i.e., Bio-Technology, Bio-Chemistry, Micro-Biology and Genetics) other than M.Sc. Botany or Zoology, they will not do justice to the basic subject of Biology upto Senior Secondary level. Further specialized branches (i.e., Bio-Technology, Bio-Chemistry, Micro-Biology and Genetics) are only the small components of the syllabus or course contents taught to the students at Senior Secondary level.