Skip to main content
Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law
Document Fragment View
Matching Fragments
My suggestion is that Dr. Rabindranath's
own intensely patriotic, ideally stimulating,
and at the same time world-embracing
Morning Song of India (Janaganamana)
should be confirmed officially, as what it has
for almost twenty years been unofficially,
namely, the true National Anthem of India."
Mr. Ram Jethmalani, the learned senior counsel leading the
intervenors, severely criticized the conduct of the petitioner who has
mentioned in the writ petition that the continued use of the word
'Sindh' in the National Anthem offends patriotic sentiments of the
citizens of India and is offensive of sovereignty of the neighbouring
country. He goes on to allege that the sentiments of 100 crore Indians
can be soothened by correcting and updating the "National Anthem".
The learned senior counsel posed the questions __ Whose cause the
petitioner is pleading ___ of the citizens of India or of a neighbouring
country? Wherefrom does the petitioner gather an impression and
plead that he is espousing the cause of more than one billion people of
India? The learned senior counsel was at pains to point out that ever
since this petition was filed in the Court and notice was directed to be
issued the Indian newspapers have been flooded with editorials and
hundreds of 'letters to the editor' highlighting the sentiments of the
people of India, and in particular of Sindhis who have felt hurt by the
move of the petitioner. There are several oppositions filed in the
Court. There is not even one who may have spoken in support of the
petitioner.