Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

Shri I.N. Singh Yadav, Advocate, who has entered appearance on behalf of opposite party no.5 has contended that once the merit of opposite party no.5 has been superior, she has every right to opt for a seat available in counselling and to say that reservation criteria has been breached cannot be accepted and as such no interference be made in the facts of the case and specially when petitioner is pursuing her course at Meerut and opposite party no.5 has been pursuing her course at Kanpur.

After respective arguments have been advanced, the factual situation that is so emerging in the present case vis-a-vis petitioner and opposite party no.5 is that petitioner was one of the candidate, who had appeared in NEET 2016 with Roll No.8750541 and the petitioner was a general category candidate/student and holds NCC category 'C' certificate. The overall rank of petitioner was 3877 in the State of U.P. while in the sub-category of NCC, petitioner has been ranked 5th all over the State. Respondent no.5 on the other hand has got State Rank 2895 in NEET 2016. Respondent no.5 is from OBC category and has also applied under OBC NCC sub-category and her sub-category rank is 4th as against the petitioner who ranks 5th. In the NCC category/sub-category the candidates at serial no.1, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 10 could not get the seats and for this reason the respondent no.5, who's name figured at serial no.9, stood at serial no.4, whereas the petitioner, who's name finds place at serial no.11, stood at serial no.5 in the NCC sub-category.

After the result of NEET 2016 has been declared, King George's Medical University, Lucknow was entrusted with the job of counselling. In the brochure in question that has been so published for NEET 2016 counselling, a full fledged mechanism for reservation has been provided for dealing with vertical reservation as well as horizontal reservation. The same reads as follows:-

vkj{k.k (Reservation) ¼v½ uhV&2016 ds ek/;e ls Hkjh tkus okyh izR;sd esfMdy dkyst esa miyC/k izR;sd ikB~;dze dh dqy lhVksa ij fuEuor^ m)Zok/kj vkj{k.k^ (Vertical Reservation) iznku fd;k tk;sxk% 1- vuqlwfpr&tkfr (S.C.) ds vH;FkhZ 21 izfr'kr 2- vuwlwfpr&tutkfr (S.T.) ds vH;FkhZ 02 izfr'kr 3- vU;&fiNM+k&oxZ (O.B..C.) ds vH;FkhZ 27 izfr'kr vU;&fiNM+k&oxZ (O.B..C.) dk rkRi;Z fo/kk;h vuqHkkx dh vf/klwpuk la0 1576@17&fo01&1¼d½11&2002 fnukad 31 vxLr] 2002 }kjk vf/klwfpr m0iz0 vf/kfu;e la[;k&1@2002 dh^^ vuqlwph&,d^^ esa bafxr oxksZa ls gSA fiNM+s oxZ ds og vH;FkhZ tks mDRk vf/kfu;e 1994 dh ^^vuqlwph&nks^^ vf/klwpuk la[;k 22@16@12&dk 2@1995 Vh-lh- fnukad 8&12&1995 }kjk ;Fkkla'kksf/kr ls vkPNkfnr u gks muds gh iq=@iq=h dks mDr vkj{k.k vuqeU; gksxk ,ao fo/kk;h vuqHkkx&1 dh vf/klwpuk la[;k&1576@l=g&fo&1 ¼d½ 11@2002 fnukad 31 vxLr] 2002 }kjk vf/klwpuk m0iz0 vf/kfu;e la[;k&1 lu 2002 Hkh izHkkoh gksxkA lkekU;&oxZ (U.R.) ds vH;kfFkZ;ksa ds lkFk ;fn mfYyf[kr dksbZ vkjf{kr oxZ dk vH;FkhZ ;ksX;rk ds vk/kkj ij p;fur gksrk gS rks mls vkjf{kr lhVksa esa lek;ksftr ugh fd;k tk;sxk] tSlk fd bl laca/k esa 'kklukns'k iwoZ esa fuxZr fd;k tk pqdk gSA vr% mijksDr izLrj&v esa mfYy[kr oxZ dh lhVksa dks Hkjus ls igys ;ksX;rk ds vk/kkj ij 50 izfr'kr lkekU; lhVksa dks Hkjk tk;sxkA Lis'ky dEiksusUV Iyku ds vUrZxr Lfkkfir fd;s tkus okys esfMdy dkWystksa esa miyC/k izR;sd ikB~;dze dh dqy lhVksa ij fuEuor ^oVhZdy^ vkj{k.k iznku fd;k tk;sxkA ¼'kklukns'k la0&18@26 o0iz0@2010@th&112&2010 fnukad 14-01-2011½ ¼1½ vuqlwfpr tkfr ,ao tutkfr ds vH;FkhZ 70% ¼II½ vU; fiNMs+ oXkZ ds vE;FkhZ 15 % ¼c½ uksV& 2016 esa fofHkUUk Js.kh ds vH;fFkZ;ksa ds fy, fuEuor *{kSfrt vkj{k.k* (Horizontal Reservation) iznku fd;k tk;sxk rFkk lHkh ikB~;dzeksa esa Hkjh tkus okyh izR;sd dkyst dh dqy lhVksa ij 'kkjhfjd :i ls fodykaxks] Lora=rk laxzke lsaukfu;ksa ds vkfJrksa ¼iq=@iqf+=;ksa ,oa iq=@iq=h o iq=@iqf=;ksa½ rFkk HkwriwoZ lSfud ¼;q) es viax@lsokfuo`Rr@'kghn½ ds iq=@iqf=;ksa] fu;ekuqlkj efgyk vH;fFkZ;ksa rFkk ch- xszfMax lfgr *lh* lfVZfQdsV/kkjh ,u-lh-lh- dSMVksa dks fuEuor~ *{kSfrt vkj{k.k*(Horizontal Reservation) iznku fd;k tk;sxk& 1- Lora=rk laxzke lsaukfu;ksa ds vkfJrksa ¼iq=@iqf+=;ksa ,oa iq=@iq=h ds iq=@iqf=;ksa½ ds fy, 02 izfr'kr 2- HkwriwoZ lSfud ¼;q) es viax@lsok fuo`Rr@'kghn½ ds iq=@iq=h ds fy, 02 izfr'kr 3- fodykax vH;fFkZ;ksa ds fy, 03 izfr'kr 4- efgyk vH;fFkZ;ksa ds fy, 20 izfr'kr 5- ch* xszfMax lfgr *lh* lfVZfQdsV ,u-lh-lh- dSMsV 01 izfr'kr ;g vkj{k.k *{kSfrt*(Horizontal) izd`fr dk gksxk vkSj mi;qZDr izR;ds Js.kh esa ;ksX;rkds vk/kkj ij p;fur vH;fFkZ;ksa dks vuqlwfpr tkfr&vuqlwfpr tutkfr@vU; fiNM+s oxZ@lkekU; Jsf.k;ksa esa ls ml Js.kh esa j[kk tk;sxk ftlls og lEcfU/kr gSaA mnkgj.kkFkZ ;fn Lora=rk laxzke lsukuh ds okLrfod vkfJrksa dks iznRr vkj{k.k ds varxZr p;fur dksbZ vH;FkhZ vuqlwfpr tkfr dk gS] rks mls vuqlwfpr tkfr ds fy, vkjf{kr lhVksa esa lek;ksftr fd;k tk;sxkA blh izdkj ;fn fodykax vH;fFkZ;ksa dks iznRr vkj{k.k ds vUrxZr p;fur dksbZ vH;FkhZ vU; fiNMs+ oxZ ;k lkekU; Js.kh dk gS rks mls vU; fiNM+s oxZ ;k lkekU; Js.kh ds fy, vkjf{kr lhVksa esa lek;ksftr fd;k tk;sxkA blh izdkj ;fn Lora=rk laxzke lsaukfu;ksa ds vkfJrksa ¼iq=@iqf+=;ksa ,oa iq=@iq=h ds iq=@iqf=;ksa½@ HkwriwoZ lSfudksa ds iq=] iq=h@fodykax@efgyk vH;FkhZ bu miJsf.k;ksa dh vukjf{kr ¼vksisu esfjV½ gS rks vuvkjf{kr ¼vksisu esfjV½ esa j[kk tk;sxkA fodykax vH;fFkZ;ksa dh fodykaxrk bl lhek rd u gks fd fpfdRlk f'k{kk esa ck/kd gksA Lora=rk laxzke lsukfu;ksa ds vkfJrksa ¼iq=@iqf+=;ksa ,oa iq=@iq=h ds iq=@iqf=;ksa½] HkwriwoZ lSfud ¼;q) es viax@lsokfuo`Rr@'kghn½ ds iq=@iqf=;ksa fodykax Js.kh ,oa *ch* xszfMax lfgr *lh* lfVZfQdsV /kkjh ,u-lh-lh- dSMsVksa ds tks vH;FkhZ bu miJsf.k;ksa esa vkosnu djsaxs] og blh miJs.kh dh vkjf{kr lhV ds fo:) lek;ksftr fd;s tk;saxsA vkjf{kr Js.kh;ksa dh lhVkas ds laca/k esa fuEufyf[kr 'krksZ dk ikyu fd;k tk;sxk%& ¼d½ vuqlwfpr tutkfr ds vgZ vH;FkhZ iwjh la[;k esa miyC/k u gksus ij bu vkjf{kr lhVksa dks vuqlwfpr tkfr ds vH;fFkZ;ksa ds }kjk Hkjk tk;sxkA ¼[k½ izek.k&i= ds fu/kkZfjr izi= iju gksus dh fLFkfr esa vH;FkhZ dks lkekU; Js.kh dh vH;FkhZ ekuk tk;sxk rFkk mldh Js.kh dks fdlh Hkh n'kk esa ifjofrZr ugha fd;k tk;sxkA ¼x½ lkekU; oxZ ds vH;fFkZ;ksa ds lkFk ;fn vuqlwfpr tkfr] vuqlwfpr tutkfr ,oa vU; fiNM+s oxZ dk vH;FkhZ ;ksX;rk ds vk/kkj ij p;fur gksrk gS rks mls vkjf{kr lhVksa es le;ksftr ugha fd;k tk;sxkA vH;FkhZ tks lkekU; Js.kh ds vH;fFkZ;ksa ds led{k esfjV ds vk/kkj ij izos'k ik;saxs mUgsa mi;qZDr vkjf{kr lhVksa dh x.kuk esa 'kkfey ugha fd;k tk;sxkA ¼?k½ vU; fiNM+s oxZ dh Js.kh ds varxZr izos'k ds bPNqd vH;fFkZ;ksa dks izek.k i= la[;k&2 ij 'kklu }kjk fu/kkZfjr izek.k i= izLrqr djuk vfuok;Z gSA ;fn ,sls vU; fiNM+s oxZ ds varxZr vkj{k.k ds ykHk ds bPNqd vH;FkhZ fu/kkZfjr izek.k i= izk:i&2 ds vUrxZr izLrq ugh djrs gSa rks mUgsa lkekU; Js.kh dk vH;FkhZ ekuk tk;sxkA ¼M-½ fodykax vH;fFkZ;ksa dks lqjf{kr lhVksa ij ,e-ch-ch-,l-@ch-Mh-lh- ikB~;dzeksa esa izos'k gsrq vH;fFkZ;ksa dks viuh fpfdRlk ijh{kk esfMdy fo'ofo|ky; rFkk jktdh; esfMdy dkystksa esa xfBr fo'ks"k esfMdy cksMZ ls djkuh gksxh vkSj mDr cksMZ }kjk bl Js.kh dks vkjf{kr lhV ds le{k mldh vH;FkZu ds laca/k esa fn;s x;s fu.kZ; vfUre :i ls ekU; gksxkA mDr fo'ks"k cksMZ ds xBu ds laca/k esa vko';d vkns'k egkfuns'kd] fpfdRlk f'k{kk mRrj izns'k }kjk vyx ls tkjh fd;s tk;saxsA esfMdy cksMZ fyf[kr ijh{kk dk ifj.kke ?kksf"kr gksus ds i'pkr dkmfUlfyax ds igys izR;sd jktdh; esfMdy dkyst esa cSBsxkA esfMdy cksMZ ds le{k dsoy mUgha vH;fFkZ;ksa dks mifLFkr gksuk gksxk tks fyf[kr ijh{kk dh esfjV ds vk/kkj ij fodykax Js.kh esa vgZ ?kksf"kr fd;s tk;saxsA dsoy egkfuns'kd] fpfdRlk f'k{kk m-iz- }kjk xfBr esfMdy cksMZ }kjk fn;k x;k fu/kkZfjr izk:i esa izek.k&i=&3 ij fn;k x;k izek.k i= gh ekU; gksxkA ;fn fdlh vH;FkhZ dh cksMZ dh jk; esa fodykaxrk ,e-lh-vkbZ- }kjk fu/kkZfjr ekudksa ds vuq:i ugha gS rks ,sls vH;FkhZ dkmaflfyax@izos'k gsrq vgZ ugha gksaxsA esfMdy dkmfUly vkWQ bf.M;k ds i= la- ,e-lh-vkbZ-&34 ¼1½ (GEN@2009- esM@2569 fnukad 21-04-2009 dh O;oLFkk ds vuqlkj izFke dkmfUlfyax esa 50% ls 70% yksdkseksVjh fMlsfcfyVh ds fodykax vH;fFkZ;ksa dks fodykax Js.kh gsrq vkjf{kr lhVsa vkoafVr dh tk;saxhA f}rh; dkmfUlfyax esa ;fn fodykax lhVsa 'ks"k jgrh gSa rks vksiu dVsxjh lhV esa 'kkfey djus ls iwoZ bu lhVksa dks 40% ls 50% yksdkseksVjh fMlsfcfyVh ds vH;fFkZ;ksa dks vkoafVr fd;k tk;sxkA½ fodykax vH;fFkZ;ksa ds fy, dsoy egkfuns'kd] fpfdRlk f'k{kk m-iz- }kjk xfBr esfMdy cksMZ }kjk fu/kkZfjr izk:i ¼izek.k&i=&3½ ij fn;k x;k izek.k i= gh ekU; gksxkA ¼p½ vuqlwfpr tkfr@vuqlwfpr tutkfr@vU; fiNM+k oxZ@ Lora=rk laxzke lsukuh ds okLrfod vkfJr vkSj HkwriwoZ lSfud ¼;q) esa viax@lsokfuo`Rr@'kghn½ds iq=@iqf=;ksa ,oa iq=h ds iq=@iqf+=;ksa dh Js.kh ds vkjf{kr vH;fFkZ;ksa ds fy, laxr Js.kh ds vH;FkhZ gksus ds lEcU/k esa le;≤ ij fuxZr 'kklukns'kksa ds vuqlkj fu/kkZfjr izk:i ij fn;s x;s izek.k&i= gh ekU; gksaxs ¼lkr iek.k&i=ksa ds izk:i layXudksa ds :i esa iznf'kZr gSa½A vuqlwfpr tkfr rFkk tutkfr ds tkfr izek.k&i= dk fu/kkZfjr izk:i izek.k&i=&4 gSA LorU=rk laxzke lsukuh ds vkfJrksa ¼iq=@iqf=;ksa ,ao iq=@iq=h ds iq=@iqf=;ksa½ }kjk vius nkos ds leFkZu esa fu/kkZfjr izk:i ds izek.k&i=&5 ij gh izLrqr djuk gksxk HkwriwoZ lSfud ¼;q) esa viax@lsokfuo`Rr@'kghn½ ds iq=@iqf=;ksa dks vius nkos ds leFkZu esa fu/kkZfjr izk:i ds izek.k&i=&6 ij l{ke vf/kdkjh }kjk tkjh izek.k&i= izLrqr djuk gksxk rFkk ^ch^ xzsfMax lfgr ^lh^ lfVZfQdsV/kkjh ,u0lh0lh0dSMsV dks vkj{k.k dk ykHk izkIr djus gsrq fu/kkZfjr izk:i ds izek.k&i=&7 ij gh izek.k&i= izLrqr djuk gksxkA ¼N½ dkfeZd vuqHkkx&2 ds 'kklukns'k la[;k& 18@1&2008&dk& 2@20015 fnukad 21-04-2015 ds vuqlkj mRrj izns'k yksd lsok ¼'kkjhfjd :i ls fodaykx LorU=k lxzkae lsukfu;ksa ds vkfJr vkSj HkwriwoZ lSfudksa ds fy, vkj{k.k½ vf/kfu;e]1993 ¼;Fkkla'kksf/kr½ esa izkfo/kkfur LorU=rk laxzke lsukfu;ksa ds vkfJr&iq=]iq=h]ikS= ¼iq= dk iq= ;k iq=h dk iq=½ rFkk ikS=h ¼iq= dh iq=h ;k iq=h dh iq=h½ }kjk fu/kkZfjr izk:i esa l{ke izkf/kdkjh@vf/kdkjh vFkkZr ftykf/kdkjh }kjk gh vkfJr izek.k&i= dkmflfyax ds le; izLrqr djuk gksxkA vH;fFkZ;ksa dks bl laca/k esa dkmaflfyax cksMZ ds le{k ewy fuokl izek.k&i= izLrqr djuk gksxk rFkk izos'k ds le; Hkh lacaf/kr dkyst ds iz/kkukpk;Z }kjk ewy fuokl izek.k&i= ls izekf.kr Nk;kizfr dh lR;rk dh iqf"V ds mijkUr gh izos'k dh dk;Zokgh lqfuf'pr dh tk;sxhA ¼t½ Lis'ky vihy la[;k&689@2015 lqjsUnz dqekj dkoar cuke ;wfu;u vkWQ bf.M;k o vU; esa ek0 mPp U;k;ky; }kjk ikfjr vkns'k fnukad 26-10-2015 ds ifjisz{; esa vU; jkT;ksa@la?k 'kkflr {ks=ksa ls mRrj&izns'k esa foLFkkfir gksdj vk;s Nk=ksa dks uhV ds vUrxZr vuqlwfpr tkfr@vuqlwfpr tutkfr ds vkj{k.k dk ykHk iznku ugha fd;k tk;sxkA"

The brochure in question also contains the Time Schedule for completion of the admission process for 1st MBBS Course, which reads as under:-

"TIME SCHEDULE FOR COMPLETION OF THE ADMISSION PROCESS FOR FIRST MBBS COURSE (Academic Session 2016-17) Schedule for Admission Seats filled up All India Quota Seats filled up by the State Govt./Institutions Conduct of National Eligibility of Entrance Test (NEET 2016) NEET 1 Conduct on 1st May 2016 NEET 2 on 24th July 2016 NEET 1 Conduct on 1st May 2016 NEET 2 on 24th July 2016 Declaration of Result of Qualifying Examination/Entrance Examination 17th August, 2016 17th August, 2016 1st Round of Counselling/Admission 22nd August to 27th August, 2016 3rd September to 5th September, 2016 Last date for joining the allotted College and Course 3rd September, 2016 By 8th September, 2016 2nd Round of Counselling/Admission 9th to 14th September, 2016 21st September to 23rd September, 2016 Last date for joining for the candidates allotted seats in 2nd Round of Counselling By 20th September, 2016 By 26th September, 2016 Commencement of Academic Session 3rd September, 2016 3rd September, 2016 Last date up to which students can be admitted against vacancies arising due to any reason Not applicable 30th September, 2016 SCHEDULE FOR ON LINE COUNSELLING (ALLOTMENT PROCESS) FOR ALL INDIA QUOTA UG (MBBS/BDS) SEATS-2016 All India Quota (Online Counselling) Sl. No. Event Duration Days Main Counselling Registration Choice Filling and Indicative Seat 22nd August to 25th August, 2016 (Registration will be open up to 5.00 P.M. of 25th August 2016 only) 4 days Exercising of Choices and Locking 25th August, 2016 (up to 05.00 PM of 25th August, 2016 1 Day Process of Seat Allotment-Round 1 26th August, 2016 1 Day Round 1 Result Publish 27th August, 2016 1 Day Reporting at the Allotted Medical/Dental College against 1st Round 26th August to 3rd September, 2016 (up to 05.00 PM of 3rd September, 2016 7 Days Exercising of Choices and Locking (Round 2) 9th September, 2016 to 10th September, 2016
Mention has been made that NCC category/sub-category is an independent/separate category, both petitioner and respondent no.5 were not in a position to have/opt for any seat in the counselling in their respective categories as females on basis of merit alone but both appeared and have been allotted seats in counselling under NCC sub-category in accordance with their overall State rank.
In reference to the chart in question, termed as Seat Chart for NEET 2016 first counselling, Director General, Medical Education and Training, U.P. at Lucknow has come up with the case, that the same gives details of "overall reservation". Petitioner on the other hand is asserting that once each seat has been caged then it has to be accepted as compartmentalised, with no liberty to cross over.