Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

6.2 PW6 Sh. Satender Dabas @ Maghoo from NGO 'War Against Corruption' is the witness, who had allegedly conducted the sting operation, however, he also turned hostile and did not support the prosecution case on material aspects. He, however, proved the complaint given by Smt. Akbari to President, NGO as Ex.PW6/A, seizure memo of broken spy cam and CD provided to him by Smt. Akbari, as Ex.PW6/B, seizure memo of complaint of Smt. Akbari and photocopy of registration certificate of said NGO, as Ex.PW6/C, Memo of Identification of Voice and Face in respect of audio-video footage contained in CD, as Ex.PW6/D, and Certificate under Sh. 65-B of Indian Evidence Act, as Ex.PW6/E. He also identified the spy cam as Ex.P2, and CD as Ex.P3 during trial.

6.3 PW7 Sh. Dalbir Singh, President of NGO War Against Corruption, is the witness who, according to the case of the prosecution, had allegedly facilitated the sting operation after receiving complaint from Smt. Akbari; having seen the contents of sting operation in the laptop; having prepared CD of sting operation contained in spy cam, and having accompanied Smt. Akbari and others to PS to get the complaint registered, and also witness to the facts that the accused had given beatings to him and having snatched the laptop, spy cam, CD and complaint, etc. He, however, also turned hostile and did not support the prosecution case on material aspects. In addition to other documents, he also proved attested copy of certificate of registration of said NGO, as Ex.PW7/A, and Certificate under S. 65-B of Indian Evidence Act, as Ex.PW7/B. He also identified the CD and spy cam during trial.

He deposed that after seeing the contents of CD, PW Satender @ Maghoo, had identified the persons appearing therein and making statement to him that he (PW Satender @ Maghoo) had recorded the said video by spy camera.

7.7 PW23 Retired ACP Dharampal was also part Investigating Officer [IO], having conducted part investigation such as seizure of broken spy camera; seizure of registration certificate of NGO War Against Corruption and complaint given to said NGO; recording of voice samples of accused and Smt. Akbari at FSL, Rohini, Delhi; seizure of cassettes; and submission of exhibits with FSL for examination.

Ex.PW4/E Entry No.2298/15 in Register No.19 Exhibit No. Description of the Exhibit Proved by / attested by Ex.PW5/A Complaint dated 09.06.2014 PW5 Sh. Amit and PW21 ACP (Retd.) Pratap Singh Mark Statement of PW5 under S. 161 PW5 Sh. Amit PW5/X1 Cr.PC Ex.PW5/B Seizure memo of Pen Drive and PW5 Sh. Amit, PW8 HC CDs Ajit Kumar, IO/ PW22 ACP (Retd.) Kailash Chandra Ex.PW5/C Transcript of audio-video PW5 Sh. Amit, PW8 HC Ajit Kumar, PW12 SI (Retd.) Prakash Chand, PW22 ACP (Retd.) Kailash Chandra Ex.PW6/A Original complaint given by Smt. PW6 Sh. Satender Dabas Akbari to President, NGO - War @ Maghoo, PW23 ACP Against Corruption. (Retd.) Dharampal Ex.PW6/B Seizure Memo of broken spy cam PW6 Sh. Satender Dabas and CD provided to PW6 by Smt. @ Maghoo, PW15 Akbari. Sh. Vijender Singh, PW23 ACP (Retd.) Dharampal Ex.PW6/C Seizure Memo of complaint of Smt. PW6 Sh. Satender Dabas Akbari and photocopy of @ Maghoo, PW15 Sh. registration certificate of the said Vijender Singh, PW23 NGO. ACP (Retd.) Dharampal Ex.PW6/D Memo of Identification of Voice PW6 Sh. Satender Dabas and Face in respect of accused @ Maghoo, PW8 HC appearing in audio-video footage Ajit Kumar, PW12 SI contained in CD. (Retd.) Prakash Chand, PW22 ACP (Retd.) Kailash Chandra Ex.PW6/E Certificate under Sh.65B of Indian PW6 Sh. Satender Dabas Evidence Act. @ Maghoo and IO/PW27 ACP Dinesh Sharma Exhibit No. Description of the Exhibit Proved by / attested by PW7/A Attested copy of certificate of PW7 Sh. Dalbir Singh, registration of NGO. President of NGO- War Against Corruption, and PW23 ACP (Retd.) Dharampal Ex.PW7/B Certificate under S. 65B of Indian PW7 Sh. Dalbir Singh, Evidence Act. President of NGO- War Against Corruption, and IO/PW27 ACP Dinesh Sharma Ex.PW16/A Seizure memo of 4 audio cassettes PW16 HC Sunny Malik, [2 originals and 2 copies] containing PW17 HC Satish Kumar, voice samples of accused and Smt. PW23 ACP (Retd.) Akbarti, recorded and prepared by Dharampal FSL Ex.PW19/A Copy of dismissal order bearing PW19 ASI Manbir No.5985-6085/HAP/ OP(P-1) dated Singh 16.05.2016 of accust/ Ct. Joginder Singh, Belt No.780/OD PIS No. 28883003 [running in seven pages] Ex.PW20/A FSL Report PW20 Sh. V. Lakshmi Narasimhan, Assistant Director (Physics), FSL, Rohini, Delhi Ex.PW21/A Letter written by PW21 to DCP to IO/ PW21 ACP [Retd.] provide original complaint of Sh. Pratap Singh Amit Kumar Ex.PW25/A Sanction order under S. 19 PC Act PW25 Sh. Brijendra for prosecution of accused Kumar Yadav, the then DCP, Outer North District, Delhi and IO/PW27 ACP Dinesh Sharma Ex.PW25/B Bio-Data of accused PW25 Sh. Brijendra Kumar Yadav, the then DCP, Outer North District, Delhi Exhibit No. Description of the Exhibit Proved by / attested by Ex.PW26/A Notice under S. 91 Cr.P.C. to SHO, PS Shahbad Dairy for providing Chitha in respect of duty of accused Joginder Singh for the relevant period Ex.PW26/B, Notice dated 01.02.2018 to the ACP, Mundka for providing the PW26 Sh. Dinesh duly attested copies of DD entries in Kumar Sharma, Retired present case FIR, as ACP /IO Ex.PW26/C Attested copies of five DD entry (Colly.) nos. 43A dated 25.04.2014, 27A (running dated 26.04.2014, 60B dated into 7 27.04.2014, 66B dated 27.04.2014 pages). and 67B dated 27.04.2014, Ex. PW27/A Notices to Nodal Officers of and concerned service providers Ex.PW27/B PW27 IO/ACP Dinesh Ex.PW27/C Notice issued to public witness Sharma namely Sh. Satender Dabas Ex.PW27/D Notice issued to public witness namely Sh. Dalbir Dabas (VIDYA PRAKASH) SPECIAL JUDGE (PC ACT) (ACB)-01 RADC/NEW DELHI APPENDIX-III SPECIMEN CHART FOR MATERIAL OBJECTS/ Muddamals [In compliance of directions issued by Hon'ble Apex Court in 'Manojbhai Jethabhai Parmar (Rohit) v. State of Gujarat' bearing Criminal Appeal No.(s) 2973 of 2023, decided on 15.12.2025.] Exhibit No. Description of the Proved by / attested by Exhibit Ex.P1 Original duty PW3 HC Raj Kumar register Ex.PW5/Article-1 Plastic box (of PW5 Sh. Amit, PW8 HC Ajit spectacles) Kumar, PW10 Smt. Gudiya @ Akbari, PW12 Retd. SI Prakash Chand, PW-20 Sh. V. Lakshmi Narasimhan, Assistant Director (Physics), FSL, Rohini, Delhi, and PW22 Retd. ACP Kailash Chandra.