were classified under three lists. List 'A' for the works to be
completed before issuance of the PCOD; List 'B' setting ... recommended issuance of the PCC
and also enclosed a punch list setting out works which required to be
completed.
13. On 13.10.2014, IRB furnished
conducted between SAIL and the respondents at site to
review the punch list points and completion of balance works before
issuance of the FAC, which
remained
incomplete. The TPE was required to prepare a list of such items
(Punch List), which was to be attached with the PCC. In terms ... appended thereto a list
of outstanding items signed jointly by the Third Party
Engineer and the Concessionaire (the "Punch List");
provided that
Linde Ag, Linde Engineering Division ... vs Deputy Director Of Income Tax on 23 April, 2014
GJRL had not
completed the items indicated in the Punch List; and (iv) GJRL had to
complete the project highway in all respects
snag list /
defects. The affidavit shall also address the points of
defects pointed out in the reply as well as the admitted
punch list
mechanical, piping,
electrical & instrumentation including optional works
are completed except Punch List."
*** *** ***
"2.2 Pre-commissioning activities (as detailed in Annexure
issued on 06.01.2017, while keeping the incomplete
works in the Punch List. The conclusion of the Arbitral Tribunal that
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
recommendation of a third-party engineer and it had
completed all punch list items as well. Therefore, withholding any
amount was impermissible. The respondent
executed and no safetyrelated items are allowed to be
put in Punch List. This is aserious negligence on the part
of theIE.
• It is also
