Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

Madhyamam Broadcasting Limited vs Union Of India on 5 April, 2023 Bench: Hima Kohli , Dhananjaya

party who has lost before it knows the reason for its decision. A speaking and reasoned order would also dispel any suspicion of arbitrariness ... held that even if the order is not a speaking and reasoned order, it would not stand vitiated. 33. For these reasons

confirmed by this Court vide order dated 15.11.2018, giving liberty to the respondent(s) to pass a fresh, reasoned order. The relevant portion ... reports were not available while passing order dated 11.8.2017 and gave liberty to pass a fresh reasoned order by considering the previous inquiry reports

reasoned order to the operative portion of the interim order dated 05.10.2017; however, their Counsel was informed that the reasoned order ... entire order is alone pronounced in open Court, pronouncement of merely the operative portion of the order, without the reasoned order made being ready, would

Pleadings .......................................................................... 39 III. Whether impugned order reflects application of judicial mind? ................... 40 (i) Importance of Reasoned Order ............................................................ 45 LAW ON VICARIOUS LIABILITY IN CRIMINAL CASES ... judicial discretion and the order passed by him is a judicial order, it is difficult to accept that the order passed

proved misconduct of willful insubordination or disobedience of lawful or reasonable order of employer and unauthorized absentism found in the departmental enquiry; alternatively That, persistent ... reasonings of the disciplinary authority, the appellate authority has also confirmed the order of dismissal dated 21st October 1993 by passing a reasoned order, which

material to justify their case/reason, even for below 50% default. There is also no provision to pass reasoned order by the Committee after giving ... passing any order affecting the legal rights of the parties. Duty to give reasons and/or recording reasons and/or passing speaking order, is essential

authority should be a speaking and reasoned order and in the absence of a speaking and reasoned order of DRP, we feel it proper ... authority should be a speaking and reasoned order and in the absence of speaking and a reasoned order of DRP, we feel it proper

Mhatre on false pretext that they refused to obey lawful and reasonable orders of their superiors while the other two workmen on the ground ... obey the orders of their superiors, it cannot be said that they wilfully refused to obey lawful and reasonable orders of their superiors. 15. Therefore

detailed show cause notice, reasonable time for reply, an examination of the response and the making of a reasoned order. According to the learned senior ... Gujarat High Court, the Court had ordered issuance of notice, receipt of reply and passing of a reasoned order. This judgment was overruled by this