relied on the evidence of the handwriting expert because the handwriting expert had given opinion about the handwritings of the accused. At the trial stage ... find out whether the alleged handwritings were forged and also with the help of the private handwriting expert, if necessary, to cross-examine the State
expert, Forensic Science Laboratory
[FSL]. It is submitted that through the private handwriting expert of
the petitioner, all the documents were tested ... report
of the private handwriting expert, the documents did not bear
signature of the complainant or his family members and thus the
documents were forged
signature of her mother in the said document with the private
handwriting expert, upon which, he came to know that the said
signature was false ... xerox copy of
the said agreement to sell to the private handwriting expert for
getting its opinion, and as per the report submitted
possession receipt. In support
of his claim, the plaintiff has filed private handwriting expert's
opinion, which was discarded by the Trial Court while ... suit, solely on the ground that it was issued by private
handwriting expert and cannot be believed.
4.3. So, the plaintiff appears to have filed
proving a report of handwriting expert of a
document privately examined by a private handwriting expert.
The same was allowed by the learned Chief Judicial ... directly and privately
obtaining opinions from either the Government or private experts
and also do not provide for receiving on record such privately or
directly
examined by
private handwriting expert at the expense of the accused. The accused is
directed to take steps within seven days ... examined by
private handwriting expert at the expense of the accused and the accused
was directed to take steps within seven days. However
lodged on 29.05.2019 that too on the basis of opinion of private
handwriting expert which could not be the basis of the allegations
contained therein ... allegations therein are based not only on the opinion of the
private handwriting expert; but, travel beyond that also. With regard
to the averments made
Srivastava, Private
Handwriting Expert as DW2.
ARGUMENTS
8. I have heard the arguments of Sh Anil Tanwar, Ld. Public
Prosecutor for CBI, Sh Jagdish Singh ... seal were not in the
writings of accused, as testified by private handwriting expert DW2 Sh
B.N. Sirivastava regarding which PW14 had not given
owner Homi Jahanjir Vesuna had got the
document examined by a private handwriting expert Shri
U.V. Upadhyaya, who expressed his opinion ... fraud and forgery committed, in which privately owned
land is sought to be grabbed, and the private handwriting
expert opinion and the FSL report, which
further submitted that the Report dated 10.12.2023 of the private
Handwriting Expert is a managed and self-serving document obtained by
Respondent ... involved competing Handwriting
Expert Reports (one by a government expert for the prosecution and another
by a private expert for the defence) along with other
