individual was subsequently considered for
2nd financial upgradation in Feb 2008. However,
the DSC did not recommend his case as he was
again assessed ... recommended by the DSC.
After the judgment of Hon'ble SC in Dev Dutt case
in 2008, the nomenclature of ACR has been
changed
time of DSC‟s meeting held on 09.10.2012, the applicant
was found charge sheeted vide Memo No.
F.5/12/2008/DOV/946-47 dated ... Directorate of Education
vide letter dated 29.05.2012 and 23.08.2012 respectively.
Hence, the DSC assessed her promotion case "As in Sealed
Cover" (Annexure
grading
2005-06 Good
2006-07 Very Good
2007-08 Very Good
2008-09 Average
2009-10 Average
2.3 The Principal, SKV, Samalka, New Delhi ... been received back with observation of District Scrutiny
Committee (DSC) that ACRs for the years 2008-09 and 2009-10 are found
'average
Screening Committee (DSC) for
this purpose met on 05.06.2014. However, on finding that
the ACR of the applicant for the year 2008 ... year 2014. The DSC met in the year 2015
and then again the case of the applicant was considered.
When the DSC
years 2004-05
2004 05 to 2008
2008-2009 were assessed by the
Departmental Screening Committee (DSC) and the DSC found
DSC under FCS as on 1.1.2010 but his case was deferred since his ACRs for four years (2006-07, 2007-08, 2008 ... foreign assignment, his ACRs for the said period was not available for DSC to consider him.
9.1 We note that the applicant
from 01.02.2006 (09.11.2007 according to the respondents) but the Departmental Screening Committee (DSC) declared him unfit on the ground that applicant could not achieve ... DSC was contrary to the law laid down by the Honble Supreme Court in Dev Dutt vs. Union of India , (2008
instead of rejecting the same outright.
8. In the instant case, the DSC met on 5.6.2014 whereas the below benchmark ACR of the applicant ... below benchmark ACR for the year 2007-08 on 19.6.2014, the DSC had already met on 5.6.2014 and considered the applicants case and kept
eligible officers for grant of NFUG to
SAG by the first DSC meeting, another proposal for grant of
NFUG to SAG was initiated, wherein ... vide its OM No.AB.14017/64/2008-
Estt(RR) dated 1.07.2010. This effective date in case of the
applicant was 3.01.2006. The case
35034/3/2008-Estt-(D) dated 19.5.2009 regarding MACP Schemes for the Central government Civilian Employees and on the recommendation of DSC which
