with the PGT Recruitment Rules, 2022 and
ignore the belatedly communicated ACRs/APARs of the Petitioner for the
years ... direction quashing the adverse remarks against
the Petitioner under the ACRs/APARs for the years 2014-15 to 2020-21;
d) Issue a writ, order
being ineligible under the ACR criteria.
6. It is contended that that no adverse entry in his ACRs/APARs had ever
been communicated ... entry/grading on the APAR/ACR to the petitioner.
15. The law relating to the recording of ACRs/APARs has been well settled
grading of 'Good' awarded to the respondent in her
ACRs/APARs for the period 2003-04 and 2004-05 be upgraded ... Server on 05/04/2024 at 00:21:33
ACRs/APARs.
4. The primary submission of the learned counsel for the
petitioner is that even
under the DACPS does not arise.
He has submitted that, ACR/APAR is assessed under a different
scheme. The same has no manner of application ... competent authority that, the
petitioner was assessed for the ACR/APAR and that, the petitioner had
obtained only a 'Good' mark
average' and these ACRs were not
communicated to him despite the fact that his ACRs/APARs for the
period ... petitioner was neither communi-
cated his downgraded ACRs, nor was he communicated his below
benchmark ACRs/APARs by the respondent.
21. This Court also considered
upgradation of the same to "Very Good" in the ACR/APAR of the year
2008-2009, was rejected. The petitioner also seeks directions ... being posted
as Assistant Inspector General (Operations), he was communicated his
APAR (ACR for the year 2008-2009). In this ACR, the Reporting Officer
Manual, in the context of
initiation of the ACR/APAR of a SP of a district, reads as follows:
‘(iii) Superintendent of Police - the report ... context of the mode and method of
preparation of ACRs/APARs of IPS Officers in the rank of SPs. Rules
review should got be confined to the
consideration of the ACR/APAR dossier'. The personal file of the
officer may contain valuable material. Similarly ... consideration by the Review Committee.
Even uncommunicated remarks in the ACRs/APARs may be taken
into consideration.
4. In the case of those officers
hence the review should not be confined to consideration
of the ACR / APAR dossier. The personal file of the officer may also
contain valuable material ... prepared and submitted by him. Even un-
communicated remarks in the ACRs / APARs may be taken into
consideration.
37. He submits that DoPT has issued
instructions of the DOPT for e.g., downgradation of grading in
ACR/APAR, denying promotion for specified number of years, etc.
7. The matter ... ACR/APAR may be inconsistent with the
grading under various parameters or attributes. Before
making the overall recommendation after considering the
APARs (earlier ACRs
