representations against ACRs/APARs.
(ii) There is non-application of mind as is evident from the APAR/ACR period 2008-09 that the impugned orders ... Member CBDT has forwarded an APAR duly initiated by him. Accordingly, NO APAR period was appended in the APAR of the applicant for the relevant
should take ACRs of lower grade into account to complete
number of ACRs. If this is also not possible, all the
available ACRs should ... applicant and entire ACR is not communicated, it does not
amount to non-communication of ACR/APAR. What the
employee
received multiple commemorations and appreciation,
especially in Naxal infested areas. The ACR/APAR of the
applicant has mostly been '9' & above ... Inquiry
Committee.
3.8 As a retaliatory measure against the applicant, his
ACR/APAR for the assessment year 2019-20 was maliciously
and arbitrarily downgraded from
were granted to the applicant on the basis of his
ACRs/APARs. In this regard, the applicant further states that
(OA No.3283/2016 ... ACRS/APARs have either been Outstanding or Very Good
since 2010, except for the period 01.04.2014 to 29.09.2014
and 30.09.2014 to 28.01.2015 which were graded
these judgments is that any representation against
the adverse entries of ACR/APAR has to be decided by an authority
higher than the authority ... made entries in the ACR/APAR.
xxx xxx xxx xxx
Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the various
judgments cited above
MACP yearly assessment from
2011 to 2015 due to
below benchmark
ACRs/ APARs
The learned counsel submitted that 3rd financial upgradation ... ACR, he
submits a representation against such remarks to the
competent authority for upgradation. In the present case, the
below benchmark ACRs/APARs were communicated
2010 (Annexure 'A-4') mandated communication of APAR/ACR
to the employees, the applicant thereafter represented, on 27.04.2016, before
the Chief Personnel Officer ... dated 14.05.2009, praying for empanelment on the ground that his?
APARs/ACRs have never been communicated to him depriving him of the ..
opportunity to represent
That the Hon'ble Tribunal be pleased to declare that ACR/APAR
periods of the applicant from ... ACR of balance portion of 2007-08 for the full year of
2007-08 and to treat gradings in all ACR/APARS as one level
considered the ACRs preceding the period in question or even
ACR of the feeder grade to complete the requisite number of
ACRs/APARs and extended ... Even if the requisite ACR/ACRs of the applicant were not
available, the respondents could have taken into account the
ACRs of the preceding period
Report/Annual Confidential Report, (APAR/ACR), of the applicant
for the years 2002-2003, 2003-2004 and 2004-2005 respectively.
2. The facts common ... these cases are that the adverse
remarks were made in the APAR/ACR of the applicant for the
reporting year in question under
