Tripathi lastly submitted that the petitioner had proposed an
alternative route for broadening the road, that is, on the agricultural
land alongside the Phirni Road ... find the petitioner‟s
alternative proposal to be feasible is reproduced hereinbelow :-
"Acquisition of Agricultural Land: That the alternative
route for the Road Over
which was earlier using the Project Highway, started opting for the
alternate route via Shahabad-Panchkula, inter alia to avoid payment
of toll ... earlier using the
Project Highway, was now found travelling along alternate routes, i.e.
Tepla-Banur-Kharar in the State of Punjab and Shahabad-Saha
NHAI consequent upon representations made by GMR
regarding development of alternate routes. Reliance was placed upon
decision in Ssangyong Engg. (Supra), wherein it is held ... substantiate diversion of the traffic from
the Project Highway to the alternate routes/competing roads as well as
the consequent loss caused
exploring avenues of access to the police
station that alternative routes to the police
station are available. Such an opportunity having
not been granted, learned ... been
taken recourse to.
37. According to the petitioners there exists
alternative route. Had no opportunity of hearing
been given, the petitioners could show that
routes to pick up routes in lieu of route No. 247.
In this regard, UTT Committee, of its own, had suggested a different route ... specified route or routes. It is this route which has been specified. The method of variation of this route is provided in clause (xxii) which
zigzag manner. It was contended the plea of the petitioner for alternate route is inaccurate as the pipeline for carrying petroleum products cannot have ... which would be dangerous to the neighborhood. This fact that the alternate route proposed by the petitioner will be too near to the neighborhood
points of
the Project Highway and serving as an alternative route thereof,
such road being an existing paved road, which has been widened
by more ... ends of the Project Highway,
(ii) which served as an alternative route to the Project
Highway, and
(iii) which was
(a) either an existing paved
basis of FOB value of exports was continued. However, an alternative route was provided to the exporters on the basis of NFE. The exporters were ... according to which the NFE route was restored as an alternative route for grant of SILs. This was done primarily for the reason that exporters
submitted
that the user could exit at Nadiad and take an alternate route (other than the
Expressway) to Vadodara and on return journey, enter ... toll plaza. He could exit at Nadiad
and then take an alternative route to go to Vadodara. On the return
journey, he would enter
Naini Bridge. Further, HCC did not
demonstrate that there was no alternative route. Lastly, as regards
Dispute No. 7, it was again submitted that there ... Page 11 of 15
Clause 70.8 of COPA. There was no alternate route to the passage
through reserved forests or the Naini Bridge. HCC notified
