duties for reviewing of the APAR.
[14]. At this stage, it would be appropriate to stated the APAR
grading of the petitioner from ... stated supra,
except the grade for the period under report i.e., 2016-2017, the petitioner's
grading in APAR remained either "very
dated 07-01-2020, the
regional office has conveyed that the APAR grading of Ms. Soma Sen Biswas has
been upgraded to 'Good ... wherein she has expressed
displeasure with the information given on her APAR grading.
6. This Commission observes that due information, as available in records
vide its order dated 25.06.2018
informed the Appellant that APAR Grading could be obtained by him through proper channel from
the Competent Authority.
HEARING:
Facts ... while reiterating the submissions of the CPIO / FAA explained that the APAR gradings of the
Appellant had already been furnished to him which he lost
applicant to be devoid of
appropriate merit and belatedly conveyed a downgraded APAR which
apparently the Reviewing Authority corrected it to the next level ... 2017/CAT//BANGALORE
grievance that even though she was given only a grading of A3 all the others
were given A2 as a grading even
APAR Gradings for last six years. The CAO cum
CPIO have denied to give him the final grading /final assessment sheet of APAR under ... modified as Annual
Performance Assessment Report (APAR).
Page 3 of 11
(ii) The full APAR including the overall grade and assessment of integrity shall
marked
values in each segment of his APAR 2011-12, overall value in percentage of his APAR grading,
etc.
The CPIO, vide its letter dated ... each segment of Assessment sheet of his
APAR and overall value in percentage of his APAR Grading as sought in the RTI application as
also
records/APAR are very good/good. But the
APAR/ACR for the year 2013-14 is an exception which has been down-
graded and declared ... applicant is that the grading of 3.5 (or effectively a grading of zero) in
his APAR for the year 2013 -2014 is unjustified
functional up-gradation (Senior Administrative
Grade) and promotion to the post of Senior
Administrative Grade to those APAR which have
been written after issuance ... APARs
since initial date of appointment. As per impugned APAR
for the year 2014-15 the applicant has been graded "Good
will be modified as Annual Performance Assessment
Report (APAR).
(ii) The full APAR including the overall grade and
assessment of integrity shall be communicated ... APAR by the
Railway or its Unit, where the APAR has been accepted.
5. It may also be mentioned that a number of APARs
reconsideration of the applicant's APAR grading for the year 2016-201 7.
Ld. Counsel for the applicant would also furnish during hearing.
another ... letter dated 25.6.1 Q.
Your appeal for reconsideration/upgradation of APAR grading for the year 201 <S-
17 cannot be acceded
