secured above 40 marks and the decision fixing minimum of 20 marks in the interview for selection to the post are arbitrary and illegal ... also. In otherwords, the marks allocated for the interview should not exceed 12.2% of the total marks viz. the marks allocated for the written test
Anju Lis Kurian vs The Mahatma Gandhi University on 17 July, 2025
Author: T.R
Dr. G.Geethika vs Mahatma Gandhi University on 17 July, 2025
Author: T.R.Ravi
have obtained 60 marks and above have been included in the main list of
the short list and that cut off marks have been lowered ... shortlist to 16, by resorting to
prescription of cut off marks, is arbitrary and illegal.
8. A statement dated 5.8.2006 has been filed on behalf
marks
and that out of the total marks, 100 marks were allotted for
written test, 80 marks for interview and 20 marks for group
discussion ... allocation of 50% marks for the interview and 50% marks on
the evaluation of the ACRs is not arbitrary". So also, in the
said
given as aforesaid it will come to 275 marks and with this increase in marks no candidate from University other than University of Rajasthan ... merit, the process of evaluation cannot be considered to be arbitrary unless marks allotted for a particular facets is on the fact of it excessive
The Chief General Manager vs Rajesh.S on 8 June, 2010
Author: T.R.Ramachandran
maximum of 20 marks.
(c) Twenty marks for administrative
ability/meritorious service.
(d) Twenty marks for additional academic
qualification - five marks for each, subject ... marks
awarded shows that three persons who scored 20 marks,
one person who scored 15 marks and one person who
scored 12 marks for experience
among the candidates and therefore fixing
of such minimum marks cannot be said to be arbitrary also. It has been
held by the Division Bench ... notification.
Such was a rational step and a non-arbitrary one. The adoption of
minimum marks is well justified since the selection
shall be open for the University to provide
grace marks upto a maximum of 5 marks to a student who
has failed only ... short 'MCI') had
permitted to grant grace marks upto a maximum of five
marks to a student in one subject, there
