India-Articles 134(1)(c) and 136(1)-certifi-
cate by High Court wrongly granted under art. 134(1)(c)
under wrong view ... them. Article 134(1) (c) uses the same language as
article 133(1) (c). A certificate is, required under
article 133(1). in each
Supreme Court falling within the scope of Article 134(1) or the enlarged jurisdiction permitted by Article 134(2) liable to shorthand hearing and peril ... difference between Articles 134 and 136 , between right and leave. The rule, in cases of appeals under Article 134(1)(a) and (b) and Section
that therefore leave should be granted under Article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution, which provides for an appeal to the Supreme Court ... granting special leave under Article 136 would equally apply when leave to appeal is sought under Article 134(1)(c).
23. With great respect
Court only under Article 134 of the Constitution. Admittedly the only provision applicable to this case is Article 134(1)(c) under which this Court ... High Court and of the Supreme Court under Article 136 and under Article 134(1)(c) are not identical. More over it appears
filed Articles 182 and 134 of the Constitution of India were relied on, the arguments before us were confined to Article 134(1)(c ... Judges with reference to the interpretation of Article 136 as in our opinion Article 134(1)(c) must be construed independently of Article
purpose of granting a certificate under Article 132(1) or Article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution, or granting bail or suspending the sentence under ... upon the certificate of the High Court under Article 132(1) or Article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution. The same reasoning was adopted
JUDI-
CIARY
(OCTOBER, 1972)
1. (a) Are you in favour of limiting the scope of criminal appeals
under article 134 of the Constitution ... under sub-clause (c) shall lie subject to
such provisions as may be made in that behalf under clause (1) of
article
giving reasons.
^
HELD:
(Per Krishna Iyer, Shinghal & Desai, JJ.)
1. Article 134(1)(c) spells a measure of seriousness
because the High Court which ... under Art. 134(1)(a) and (b) as provided for in Art.
134(2) of the Constitution. [1117C]
4. Article 145(1)(b) enables
Criminal Application has been taken out for a certificate under Article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution of India that this case ... final order within the meaning of Article 134 of the Constitution?
8. Article 134(1)(c) requires that before a certificate could be issued
APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No. 86 of
1954.
Appeal under Article 134(1)(C ) of the Constitution of India
from the judgment and order dated ... ordered that a certificate for
leave to appeal under article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution
may be drawn up. In an elaborate judgment
