better method to verify support.Those who support the check off system argue:
(i) that the check off or authorization to deduct union subscriptions from ... secret ballot which only shows the preference at the moment, the check off system shows the continued support for the unions over a long enough
systems viz(i) Check off System or Physical
Verification System and (ii) Secret Ballot System, a
Single Bench in Moil Janshakti Mazdoor Sangh vs.
Union ... Check off System or Physical
Verification System and (ii) secret
ballot system. The debate as to which
is the best method for recognizing the
representative
strength of the Unions especially when there is a valid check-off system prevailing in the industry. It is further alleged in the affidavit that ... members and that they are paying subscription to the Union under check-off system. It is made clear in the said letter that
trade unions functioning in the 1st
respondent by implementing the check off system and deducting the
subscription of the members of the Writ petitioner ... trade unions functioning in the 1st respondent by
implementing the check off system and deducting the subscription
deducted directly from their salaries verification of membership strength through 'check off system' is not feasible. Therefore, representation was given to the society ... Union concerned. The Division Bench has found that the check off system has lost its appeal. A combined understanding of the Trade Union Act read
cannot be enforced. He further submitted that there is already a Check Off system which is one of the modes of recognizing registered trade unions ... membership through the secret ballot system is more scientific and a better system compared to check off system or any other system
cannot be enforced. He further submitted that there is already a check-off system which is one of the modes of recognizing registered Trade Unions ... their membership. It is submitted by Mr. Sinha that, as per check-off system, membership of respondent Nos. 3 and 5 Unions is verified
other mode of
ascertainment/verification such as secret ballot or check off system would
be time consuming, expensive, and would lead to friction and labour ... recognition as a Service
Association shall be done by the 'check off system in pay rolls'. Para
2.4 of the clarification issued
which union did enjoy the majority support, either by adopting
the check off system or through an election. To support his contention Mr.
Bhattacharya relied ... support of majority of the
workmen could be ascertained either through check off system or through an
election. The Apex Court considered such issue
majority of workmen as its members. As per the check off system, the Sangha enjoyed the majority support of workmen and after negotiations, the settlement ... evidence to demonstrate that majority workmen are its members. By following check off system, it was found that the Sangha enjoyed the support of majority
