INTENDED TO CONFER A RIGHT
ON THE STATE TO MAKE ANY FRESH LEVY OR COLLECTION IN RESPECT OF
THE CESS AND TAXES, WHICH COULD ... THAT THERE IS NO RIGHT IN THE STATE TO MAKE ANY FRESH
LEVY OR COLLECTION AND ONLY THE LEVIES ALREADY COLLECTED WOULD
NOT BE REFUNDED
article 19(1)(f) and (g) of the Constitution.
29. Fresh levy : In contrast, when a fresh levy is imposed retrospectively by any legislation ... existing law, the length of the retrospective operation of a fresh levy does become relevant while considering the extent of hardship which the assessed would
there was no power in the legislature to make an altogether fresh levy and tax retrospectively what was not so under ... Haryana is on equally firm ground that even an altogether fresh levy of tax with a retrospective effect is also wholly within the competence
remove the deficiency or the cause of invalidity. However, a fresh levy of tax
or the withdrawal of an exemption, unambiguously granted is never
permissible ... cause of invalidity but in essence seeks
to impose a fresh levy for the first time which is unreasonable and arbitrary;
-(viii) Under Sub-section
Aircel Cellular Ltd vs Union Of India on 11 August, 2016
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh
dismissed as fully satisfied, fresh execution without getting the sale set aside is barred and no fresh execution can be levied, because, an order ... passed in it granting permission to the decree-holder to levy fresh execution. That order can very well be said to be an order impliedly
cause of invalidity but, in essence,
seeks to impose a fresh levy of tax on the appellant for the first time, which is
unreasonable ... imposition of a new levy and the imposition of a
fresh levy with retrospective effect was violative of Article 14 of the Constitution and
repelled
Validating Act imposes a fresh levy which is impermissible. He relied
upon the learned opinion expressed by Justice G.P. Singh in his well
known ... Regional Transport Authority7. He submitted that in
any case a fresh levy with retrospective effect cannot be imposed under
the Validating Act. He relied upon
Validating Act imposes a fresh levy which is impermissible. He relied
upon the learned opinion expressed by Justice G.P. Singh in his well
known ... Regional Transport Authority7. He submitted that in
any case a fresh levy with retrospective effect cannot be imposed under
the Validating Act. He relied upon
2016 00:20:52 :::
Judgment-WP.1009.1998.doc
manner levy fresh taxes for the first time as falsely
alleged. If the Package Scheme ... without jurisdiction.
(f) The amendment is in no way imposing fresh levy in
the present context inasmuch as the scheme, agreement,
Page
