Goodwin vs Brewster (H.M. Inspector Of Taxes). on 9 February, 1951
Equivalent citations: [1952]22ITR31(CAL)
JUDGMENT
DANCKWERTS, J., - This is an appeal ... Goodwin from a decision of the Special Commissioners of Income Tax upholding assessments made upon him under Schedule E of the Income
fact and my reasons as briefly as possible.
16. Florence S. Goodwin in her affidavit dated 6-8-1952 says :
"Your deponent knows that ... Registrar is wrong. The statement of the deponent Florence S. Goodwin on affidavit that a substantial business in India since 1930 has been done
Supreme Court
approved the observation of the English decision in Wilkes versus
Goodwin, where it was held that the rent would include total payment
made ... language of younger L.J. in the case of Wilkes versus
Goodwin 1923-2 KB 86 which was quoted by the Hon'ble Supreme
Inland Revenue [1921] 3 K.B. 344 at p. 355 Wilkes v. Goodwin [1923] 2 K.B. 86 Mullins v. The Treasurer of the County ... inconvenience or hardship is irrelevant.
49. In the case of Wilkes v. Goodwin (1923] 2 K.B. 86 it was held that where the language
respondent at 13, Telkul Ghat Road, committed incestuous adultery with Ada Goodwin, the sister of the petitioner, who was then residing with your petitioner
decree, a view which is supported by the cases of Cotton v. Goodwin 7 M. & W. 147, Dixon v. Clark
Cockburn C.J. referred to the same practice in his judgment in Goodwin v. Roberts
left to the Jury. To the fame effect is the decision in Goodwin v. Robarts (1875) 10 Ex. 337 on Appeal
allowed to defeat the right which the plaintiffs have thus acquired: Goodwin v. Robarts (1876) L.R. 1 A.C. 476. No thing has been
Quilon Bank Ltd., G. Samuel v. Cyril Gill and John Stanley Goodwin, AIR 1941 Mad 622 in such a case the owner of the security
