between the parties. On the issue of identical IP addresses, it has
averred that, shared IP address can be due to multiple legitimate reasons such ... sequentially numbered and were tendered by
OP-9, who did not participate in this tender.
The IP addresses from which
that the IP address, being
unique to a router and no two routers on the network can have the same IP
address, therefore, went ... IP address is the same would reveal cartel formation is too
large an ask for this Court to accept. Merely because the IP address
said tender.
Internet Protocol Address used for Uploading Tender Documents:
32. Furthermore, in case of Tender no. 62 of 2014, out of the four qualified ... were found to have the same IP Address.
Whereas OP-2 and the ineligible bidder had different IP Address
only.
11.3. OP-2 used its own IP address for filling up the tenders of all three
bidders, i.e. for itself ... evidence
collected by the DG, viz. usage of single IP address, price parallelism,
submission of Tender Charges by OP-2, CDR analysis, close relationship
between
from a common IP address:
S. No. Tender No. Tender floated by Opening date Common IP addresses ... Tender No. Tender floated by Opening date Common IP addresses
14. 70160069 Southern Railways 23.03.2017 OP-2 and OP-5
15. 07181538 Northern Railways
behalf of M/s Mahalaxmi Steels
The IP address used for uploading the documents for the
tenders is the same for various bidders
The statement ... from one of the computer device of OP-
3 (using IP address-114.143.199.34) in tender no. 21 of 2013.
As such, there could be some
incriminating conducts
like using the same invoices, submission of tender from same IP address,
submission of tender from same Login ... Satish Kumar were submitted
from the same IP Address in the Bareilly tenders of 2018. Further, in
the Moradabad tenders of 2018, the bids
quoted in any of the tenders through a common IP address with any
other OP.
10.9 Further, the inherent nature of the market for Protective ... from a
common IP address:
S. No. Tender No. Tender floated by Opening date Common IP addresses
1. 11142530-A Central Railways
Uploading Tender Documents:
18. Further, in Tender nos. 21 of 2013, the DG noted that the same Internet Protocol
address (hereinafter, 'IP address ... from the IP address within a
gap of two hours. On examination of IP addresses of parties that had bid for
Tender
OMCs,
data and documents including bid details for the Impugned Tender, IP addresses from
which the bids were quoted in the Impugned Tender, replies from ... vague and
imaginary.
26.11 The DG has ignored the e-mails, IP addresses, travel plans, copies of ledger
accounts, and minutes of ISMA meetings collected
