President (Engineering Hotel), had also been proceeded against departmentally on almost identical charges as the Applicant and was acquitted, inter alia, on the ground that ... that Shri LR Pahwa, the then VP, was exonerated of the identical charges on the same ground. The Applicant has made this averment in paragraph
with the disciplinary enquiry when a criminal
case is pending on identical charges...........The only
ground suggested in the above decisions as constituting
a valid
Appeal Nos. 102,103 & 112 of 2010
between the distribution charges of identical
consumers connected at different nodes in the
distribution network. It would
case of Shri R.N. Mishra, who had been exonerated of the charges. Appreciation of evidence by both was different and cannot be compared ... justice if one officer were to be held guilty for identical charges and on the evidence of the same witnesses, whereas the other was exonerated
tried for identical charges in criminal matter and has been acquitted. The decision vitiates the various charges which are identical but have been held proved
reply to the said charges, the
Administrator exonerated the petitioner from those charges and withdrew the
charges framed against the petitioner by his letter dated ... present Managing Committee cannot suspend him once
again by bringing identical charges against him.
Be that as it may; fact remains that during the pendency
which the disciplinary
proceedings are proposed to be held identical or nearly similar to the
charges on which they are facing criminal proceedings ... with the
disciplinary enquiry when a criminal case is pending
on identical charges. The staying of disciplinary
proceedings, it is emphasised, is a matter
with the disciplinary enquiry when a criminal
case is pending on identical charges. The staying of
disciplinary proceedings, it is emphasised, is a matter ... identical facts and
the evidence in the matter, it was also required to take
into consideration the question as to whether the
charges leveled against
Penal Code. He was proceeded with departmentally for
misconduct principally on the identical charge. He was also proceeded with for an additional charge of
unauthorised ... from the Criminal Court, the Disciplinary Authority punished him on the identical
charges as according to them the allegations were proved in the departmental enquiry
started another departmental proceeding for enquiring into the very same and identical charges on which
they wanted to proceed earlier. If these two Articles ... charges are read simultaneously, then this Court
finds that not only the wordings of those two set of charges are exactly identical, but also
