Safia alias Shafiqun Nisha (identically placed to that of the present revisionists) have already been tried for identical charges, on the basis of identical evidence ... testimonies of the identical witnesses.
22. This Court is also of the view that once for identical charges and on the basis of the identical
workmen were suspended and subsequently dismissed
on the basis of identical charges, and their services
were terminated without conducting any departmental
inquiry. However, instead ... labour
practice by discriminating against the concerned
workmen, inasmuch as, for identical charges of
misconduct, all other similarly situated workmen were
reinstated, whereas only
with the disciplinary enquiry when a criminal case is pending on identical charges. The staying of disciplinary proceedings, it is emphasised, is a matter ... with the disciplinary enquiry when a criminal case is pending on identical charges. The staying of disciplinary proceedings, it is emphasised, is a matter
from the criminal prosecution
on the ground that for identical charges he has been
exonerated in regular departmental enquiry by as many as
CRMC ... departmental proceedings would lead to
quashment of criminal proceedings on identical charges in
the case of Sarwan Singh vs. State , 2020 SCC OnLine
same facts based on the
informant’s written complaint and identical charges being involved, after
the appellant’s exoneration in the criminal proceedings, rendered ... criminal proceedings, which seem to have involved substantially similar
or identical charges, evidence, witnesses, and circumstances.
ISSUE NO. 3
54. The Division Bench
that the departmental
proceedings were instituted against the accused-
appellant on identical charges and same set of facts
and evidence and have culminated
with the
disciplinary enquiry when a criminal case is pending on
identical charges...........The only ground suggested in the
above decisions as constituting a valid ... contended by the learned advocate that the similar
charges and for identical misconduct a lenient view was
taken by the employer. This Court is unable
with the disciplinary enquiry
when a criminal case is pending on identical charges.
The staying of disciplinary proceedings, it is
emphasised, is a matter
with the delinquency
and once charges are established, to award appropriate
punishment. But when the charges are same and identical
in relation ... with
the delinquency and once charges are
established, to award appropriate
punishment. But when the charges are
same and identical in relation
were tried for the same set of similar and identical charges
and when there are similar ... identical evidence for all the accused,
acquitting A2 to A4 alone from the same set of similar and identical
evidence from all the charges would
