OP-2 is a 100% subsidiary of OP-1 through Esaote International N. V.
C. No. 09 of 2016 15
Thus, OP-1 and OP ... made by OP Group
concluded that OP-1 has entered into in an agreement with OP-2 giving
exclusive rights to OP
counsel for OP-1 further submitted that the Distribution Agreement between OP-1
and OP-2 pertained only to offline sales and not online sales ... offline sales and not with respect to
online sales of products. Since no rights for online sales has been given to OP-1,
the question
Informants alleged that the inter se
agreements of OP-1 with OP-2 and OP-3 to sell counterfeit/unlicensed/unauthorised
products are anti-competitive ... Informants have stated that OP-2 and OP-3 are affiliates of or related entities
of OP-1. OP-1 leverages its control over
been importing VSF
products from its group companies such as OP-3 and OP-4 located in
Thailand and Indonesia respectively without paying any such ... OP-2 in the relevant market.
20. Having held OP-2 to be dominant, the DG delved into examining the alleged
abusive conduct of OP
authorised only by the OP. The rates
of each of these products/services were also prescribed by the OP. The OP set a
target ... OP as the OP debits the Informant's account and the
Informant is left with no choice. The OP also allegedly gave threats
which penalise and restrict online sales and cross-regional sales
amount to using unfair practices by the OP by sharing the market or dividing ... such restriction against sales outside the Sales Region, the Informant
has been given the exclusive right to sell within the Sales Region, it is evident
avoid price wars among themselves. As such, OP-1,
OP-3, OP-4 and OP-5 have contravened the provisions of Section ... Sharing Sales and Stock Data - OP-1, OP-3 and OP-4 have also been sharing their
periodical sales and sales data with each other
Producers with own mining capability and retail sales; and (c) Export
sales. Also, the OP produces three different grades of Ilmenite ... pricing methodology followed by the
OP or the factors considered by the OP in pricing Ilmenite. As per the OP, the DG has
erred
calculated by
dividing sales value by sales volume.
33.8. The DG has done inaccurate assessment of size and resources of OP with
size and importance ... should consider (a) relevant turnover of OP in
India, i.e. OP's turnover from sales of BMPs for desktop PCs in India
Aktiengesellschaft ('OP-2') and Siemens Healthcare Pvt. Ltd.
('OP-3') (collectively referred to as 'OPs'/'OP Group ... OP-1
and OP-2 stated that its name is liable to be struck off from the array of OPs.
Submission of OP
