proceedings and the punishment imposed is disproportionate with the delinquency, set aside such punishment and directed the appellant to impose a punishment other than removal ... superannuation benefits.
ii) The learned Single Judge, while dealing with the proportionality of punishment of removal from service with superannuation benefits as per rules failed
along with connected
appeal, have laid down the social effect of punishment
and proportional considerations, when the principle of
rarest of rare rule ... that criminal law requires
strict adherence to the rule of proportionality in
providing punishment according to the culpability
of each kind of criminal conduct keeping
Om Prakash Sharma vs Legislative Assembly Of The National ... on 30 October, 2018
Equivalent citations
however grave it may appear to be;
(vii). go into the proportionality of punishment unless it shocks
its conscience.
14. In one of the earliest ... Constitution of India, to go into the
proportionality of punishment so long as the punishment
does not shock the conscience of the court
courts or tribunals should
not go into the issue of proportionality of punishment
unless it shocks its conscience. The Hon'ble Supreme
Court ... however grave it may
appear to be;
(vii). go into the proportionality of punishment
unless it shocks its conscience."
19] The parameters of judicial
Mahendra Nath Verma vs U.P. State Public Services Tribunal ... on 4 September, 2018
Author
Santosh Kumar Paswan vs State Bank Of India & Ors on 17 December, 2018
Author
however grave it may
appear to be;
(vii) go into the proportionality of punishment unless it
shocks its conscience.
18. While considering the scope ... Constitution of India to
consider issue of the proportionality of punishment so long as the
punishment does not shock the conscience of the Court
Constitution of India, to go into the proportionality of punishment so long as the punishment does not shock the conscience of the court ... open to the High Court to go into the proportionality of punishment or substitute the same with a lesser or different punishment. These aspects have
Constitution of India, to go into the proportionality of punishment so long as the punishment does not shock the conscience of the court ... open to the High Court to go into the proportionality of punishment or substitute the same with a lesser or different punishment. These aspects have
