building's age (60
years) without sufficient evidence or structural audit certification. He
contended that MHADA had no authority to issue the notice ... documentation, such as a panchnama or formal
certification by a Structural Engineer. A structural audit report was obtained
just a day before the order, suggesting
basement, slabs, walls,
lintels, plaster, concrete of all the structures
have deteriorated. The structural audit has been
conducted by the Government College of Engineering ... tenements are load bearing structures. There
are no RCC columns and beams in the said
structures. The structural audit team was given
access
Consulting Civil Engineers and Structural Consultants. They have
submitted a report styled as 'Structural Audit Report' on 18 th
April, 2015 opining that ... called upon, together with Respondent No.7, to submit a fresh
Structural Audit Report and that was also done by the Petitioners.
A copy
from 4 th D
Design Structural Designer, a Structural Consultant. Under the said report, it
was recommended that the structure ought to be demolished ... said structure had been pulled down while the remaining half structure which
was in a dilapidated condition was found standing. The remaining structure
was also
from 4 th D
Design Structural Designer, a Structural Consultant. Under the said report, it
was recommended that the structure ought to be demolished ... said structure had been pulled down while the remaining half structure which
was in a dilapidated condition was found standing. The remaining structure
was also
forwarding a copy of a
structural audit report. Even at that time the Society said that it
was in the process of redevelopment. About ... structural report of
5th August 2022 of one Aaryan Consultants forwarded to the
MCGM on 17th August 2022. That structural audit report is
addressed
forwarding a copy of a
structural audit report. Even at that time the Society said that it was
in the process of redevelopment. About ... structural report of 5th
August 2022 of one Aaryan Consultants forwarded to the MCGM
on 17th August 2022. That structural audit report is addressed
said structure, and if the said structure was more
than 30 years old, was any structural audit report
submitted by the owner/occupier thereof, either ... such the structure was
8 to 9 years old and there was no requirement of
getting structural audit done for that structure
June, 2022 passed by this Court permitting the
petitioner to obtain structural audit report from VJTI within four weeks
from the date of the said ... submitting audit
report, VJTI has refused to accept the assignment of structural audit
report on the request of the petitioner.
3. Learned counsel appearing
building requires substantial repairs. Mr Vanoo
submits that a structural audit was carried out in 2017-2018 when
the building was found ... Petitioners are members, obtained a "E"stage-managedW
structural audit report of 3rd June 2019 to show that the building
