recovered from the
accused or from the witnesses. DNA testing
on samples such as saliva, skin, blood, hair or
semen not only helps to convict ... there is evidence to show tampering of the
samples, the DNA test report would be unsafe to be made a
basis for convicting the accused
recovered from the
accused or from the witnesses. DNA testing
on samples such as saliva, skin, blood, hair or
semen not only helps to convict ... there is evidence to show tampering of the
samples, the DNA test report would be unsafe to be made a
basis for convicting the accused
recovered from the
accused or from the witnesses. DNA testing
on samples such as saliva, skin, blood, hair or
semen not only helps to convict ... there is evidence to show tampering of the
samples, the DNA test report would be unsafe to be made a
basis for convicting the accused
recovered from the
accused or from the witnesses. DNA testing
on samples such as saliva, skin, blood, hair or
semen not only helps to convict ... there is evidence to show tampering of the
samples, the DNA test report would be unsafe to be made a
basis for convicting the accused
Nagappa Vs.
State of Karnataka ( supra) and argued that, it is highly unsafe
to rely on DNA Test Report, in the absence of any independent ... samples of the
accused, not ruled out. In this context, the Co-ordinate Bench of
this Court has held that, it is highly unsafe
Forensic Science
Laboratory, Mumbai has stated that he did not receive the sample in a
thermos containing fetus. In view of this material inconsistency between ... custody of D.N.A. sample is seriously under cloud of suspicion. In the
above background, it is unsafe to rely upon
quite unsafe to record conviction of
the appellant barely on suspicion.
Drawing attention of this Court to the infirmities in the
samples sent
view of the
two contradictory reports of chemical analysis of the sample of vaginal
swab and smear (Ext. P-2 and P-9), the benefit ... accused. In this regard, it has been submitted that the sample in
respect of which Ext. P-2 report was submitted was taken
examination was carried out despite the fact
that the blood sample of the appellant was taken. It is further
submitted that merely because semen was detected ... that of the appellant and
in absence thereof, it would be highly unsafe to convict the appellant.
7. Mr.Qayum submitted that the testimony
stains were
found on the relevant material objects and the liquid
blood sample sent had disintegrated and therefore not
available for examination. Thus, the prosecution ... prosecution's case, and therefore, it
would be very unsafe to rely upon the testimonies of the
victim or her mother, and if their
