V.N. Devadoss vs Chief Rev. Control Officer-Cum-Ins.& ... on 8 May, 2009
Author: Arijit Pasayat
Bench: Mukundakam Sharma , D.K. Jain , Arijit ... Arising out of SLP (C) No. 3920 of 2007)
V.N. Devadoss ..Appellant
Versus
Chief Revenue Control Officer-cum-Ins.
and Ors. ..Respondents
JUDGMENT
V.N.Devadoss vs The Chief Revenue Control Officer on 27 November, 2006
Bench: P.Sathasivam , S.Tamilvanan
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE ... Justice S.TAMILVANAN
Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No.639 of 2006
= = = = =
V.N.Devadoss ... Appellant
vs.
1. The Chief Revenue Control Officer
CUM Inspector General
under Section 47A as
applicable to State of A.P. In V.N.Devadoss vs. Chief Revenue
Control Officer-cum-Inspector and Ors. reported ... correct
stamp duty." (emphasis supplied by petitioners)
8. In V.N.Devadoss 's case (decided in 2009) the Apex Court
considered a similar
following the decision of
the Supreme Court in case of V N Devadoss V.
Chief Revenue Control Officer-CUM-INS
reported ... counsel for the respective parties, the
decision in the case of V N Devadoss (supra) of
the Supreme Court which considered the
question
relied upon 2009
Volume 7 Supreme Court Cases page 438 ( V.N. Devadoss v. Chief
Revenue Control Officer-cum-Inspector & Ors. ) and has submitted ... does not
arise.
Learned Advocate for the State has submitted that, V.N.
Devadoss (supra) was considered by a Larger Bench of this
petitioner relied on the following decisions:
(2009) 7 SCC 438 [V.N.Devadoss V.Chief Revenue Control Officer-cum-Inspector and others]
13. Sub-sections ... Supreme Court of India reported in V.N.Devadoss v. Chief Revenue Control Officer-cum-Inspector and others , 2009 (7) SCC 438, held that Section
Court in the judgments reported in ( i)(2009) 7 SCC 438 V.N.Devadoss v. Chief Revenue Control officer-cum-Inspector General of Registration ... Court has in the judgment cited above ( 2009) 7 SCC 438 V.N.Devadoss v. Chief Revenue Control officer-cum-Inspector General of Registration
context of judgment of the Supreme
Court in the case of V.N.Devadoss Vs. Chief Revenue
Control Officer-cum-Inspector and Others reported ... Apex Court in
the case of V.N.Devadoss (supra) wherein in paragraphs 13,
14, 15, 16 & 18, it has held as under
affixation of
stamp duty.
1. Govt. of Andhra Pradesh & Ors .v. P. Laxmi Devi1, which
arose under Section 47A as applicable to Andhra Pradesh ... time in several states to
determine the correct stamp duty.
2. V.N. Devadoss v. Chief Revenue Control Office-cum-
Inspector & Ors.2 , which
prima facie finding that there is an under valuation.
(V.N.Devadoss's case)
c). The circle rate or the Collector's rate ... when the market valuation is
best obtained through competitive bidding (V.N.Devadoss's case (SC)).
f). If the date of auction/allotment
