changing the original entries made by
the Reporting Authority-respondent No. 5. The adverse entries made in the
ACR’s of the appellant ... representation against the adverse entries. It was
further contended by the learned senior counsel that the favourable entries
recorded in the ACR
original entries made by the Reporting
3 AIR 1979 SC 1622
15
Authority-respondent No. 5. The adverse entries
made in the ACR ... representation against the adverse entries. It was
further contended by the learned senior counsel
that the favourable entries recorded in the ACR
necessary that
there must be an adverse entry or adverse entries in the ACRs of a person for him
to be prematurely retired under Rule ... petitioner submitted a note dated 18
June 1991, regarding adverse entries in his ACR for 1989. Vide
Memorandum dated 19 July 1991 the petitioner
basis of the adverse
entry, are forthcoming.
In the absence of reasons and any material, whether the adverse
MONIKA entry of doubtful integrity recorded against ... Government of Haryana, which
provide that when an adverse entry in the ACR doubting the integrity of an
officer is to be made, it should
petitioner
and dismissed the appeal. Subsequently, however, the
adverse entries in the ACR of the first respondent for
the year 198889, stood expunged ... once the adverse remarks
have been expunged, they have to be construed as being
nonexistent. The adverse entries in the ACR of the
first
years, but his service
record, particularly the adverse entry in his ACR for the period from
01.04.2009 to 11.11.2009 (Annexure R-4), where ... pass such an order. In the instant case, the aforesaid
adverse entry in the ACR of the appellant has been upheld by the Civil
Court
Annexure P-8), petitioner's Representation against the
adverse entries in the ACR was dismissed.
2. Vide order of 4th December, 2001 (Annexure ... service record. However, the challenge of
petitioner to adverse entries in ACR is concerned, I find no justification
to expunge them. To the aforesaid extent
contention before the Tribunal was that there were certain
uncommunicated adverse entries in his ACR, which had been taken
into account by the Selection Committee ... Tribunal,
noticing the regulation, which specifically provides that
uncommunicated adverse entries in the ACR cannot be used, made
out a case that the ACR
procedure, the adverse remarks in an ACR may be found vitiated, but such
is the procedure regarding adverse entries in the confidential report ... would
have adverse ramification on promotional prospects of the employee. The
procedure laid down for making adverse entries in the ACR cannot be
applied
Raised
Reply
1
The applicant was never ever communicated any adverse entry or adverse ACRs nor supplied with the copy of the ACRs ... regarding upgradation/promotion.
3
The applicant was never communicated any adverse entry/adverse ACR he had bonafidely believed that his ACRs were not adverse
