High Court had
considered un-communicated adverse remarks recorded in the Annual
Confidential Report without informing him that the same were being relied
upon ... unreasonable and
unjustified. Learned counsel emphasized that none of the four Annual
Confidential Reports mentioned in paragraph 30 of the impugned order were
communicated
that too wrongly; they have erred in
taking into consideration the Annual Confidential Reports from
1.4.2003 to 31.03.2008; the relevant Annual Confidential Reports ... Selection Committee has rightly
taken into consideration the Annual Confidential Reports of those
years only, and therefore the impugned judgments
Since long there had been in force a system of writing annual confidential reports. Since 1974 or 1975 a system of assignment appraisal was also ... confidential reports. In fact this was being done before the gradual introduction of appraisal reporting system. Each report of an officer, whether an annual confidential
Roster be started with category of Specialists-
Government action whether valid.
Annual Confidential Report-Initiated by an officer who
is junior and also an aspirant ... confidential reports were initiated by an
officer not only junior but also an aspirant for promotion
to the higher post and therefore such Confidential reports
educational qualifications, experience in line as Tehsildar and Naib-Tehsildar and annual confidential reports recorded by their superior officers. Much fault cannot be found with ... been done fairly so far as the assessment of annual confidential reports etc. are concerned.
16. Although it was decided that annual confidential reports
jurisdiction including the power of appraising the work and recording the annual confidential reports of Presiding Officers. (1A) [ For the purpose of exercise of general
petitioner, thus, has also made a challenge to this
annual confidential report, besides challenging the order of his
compulsory retirement.
CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO.13109 ... impugn the order of his compulsory
retirement and for expunging the annual confidential report, which
primarily formed the basis of order compulsorily retiring the petitioner
assessed the work of respondent on the basis of his Annual
Confidential Report Dossier. D.P.C. found work of Respondent ... being O.A.
No. 1621/90 challenging adverse remarks in his Annual
Confidential Reports for the period 16th July, 1986 to 31st
December
issue in regard to
recording of the adverse remarks in the annual confidential report
would arise. Being aggrieved against the view taken by the Trial ... filed a suit to challenge the
adverse remarks recorded in his annual confidential report for the
period from 2.10.2003 to 28.1.2004. Prayer was to expunge
Officers and they do not have any adverse remarks in the Annual Confidential Reports. What was required under the rule was consideration of the cases ... condition that there are no adverse remarks in the last 3 annual Confidential Reports of the concerned Court Officers. Instead of following the rule, which
