been mentioned and taken into
consideration. Similarly instead of taking the APARs/Performance report for the
last three years ... APAR pertaining to 2017 has also been taken
into consideration by the respondents against the instructions of the Chief
Personnel Officer, South Western Railway, Hubli
Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking the following reliefs:
"(i). Quash the entire APAR of the Applicant at
Annexure-A12 reported by the III-Respondent ... Quash the decision of the Reviewing Officer made
in the APAR of the Applicant at Annexure: A-12 on
12.08.2016 in its entirety;
(iii) Quash
DRTC are based on candidates' performance in assessment board and
average APAR marks which may result in juniors superseding seniors.
After receipt ... performance in assessment board during 2010-2013 year wise and
also the APAR marks obtained by him for the years 2004-2012 year
wise
except
one year. The applicant has culled out his grading
from his APAR from the year of his appointment till the
latest APAR which ... evident from the
tabulation above. As the bench mark of APAR required
for promotion from the post of Inspector to
Superintendent of Central Excise
applicant to be devoid of
appropriate merit and belatedly conveyed a downgraded APAR which
apparently the Reviewing Authority corrected it to the next level ... assess her technical competence as a part of assessment of her
APAR, he called her and questioned her, which cannot be termed as a
humiliation
refused to expunge false
adverse remarks made in the applicant's APAR of 2015-16 and to
consider her promotion at par with ... opportunity was given to the applicant
before making such remarks in the APAR. The applicant further
contends that every warning/reprimand/displeasure issued in writing
working at
Shimla as School Assistant.
b) The applicant's APAR (Annual Performance Appraisal Report) for the
year 2016-17 was awarded ... applicant represented to the higher authority against his down
grading of APAR (Annexure A-6). Applicant had sent advance copy
of his representation dated
Annexure A-16), vide which his
representation dated 20.6.2019 for rectifying the APAR grades
assigned by the Reviewing Officer for the year 2017, has been ... rejected.
b) Direct the respondent No.2 to restore the APAR ratings assigned by the
First Level Authority in the APAR 2017 and consequently promote
Open-Annual
Performance Appraisals Reports with particular reference to the
ACRs/O-APARs for 5 preceding years. As per rules, in evaluating the
ACRs ... APARs, the DPC shall not be guided merely by overall
grading recorded by the Reporting/Reviewing Officer in ARCs/O-
APARs, but should make
Infantry Road,
Bengaluru -560001.
6. The Joint Deputy Director/ACR,
APAR Cell, Intelligence Bureau Hqrs.,
No.35, Sardar Patel Marg,
Bapu Dham,
New Delhi ... following
reliefs:
OA No.1125/2019
"i. To set aside the APAR 2017-18
18 and APAR 2018
2018-19 vide
Orders dated
