these rules, no preference was given
to the trained apprenticeship. Even the advertisement did not
indicate any preference to the trained apprentices. Learned senior
counsel ... preferred to the younger. Therefore, it is evident that
consciously the State had not provided for any preference to be
given to the trained apprentices
vacancies for apprentice trainees."
(emphasis added)
15. Proceeding then to examine the rights of the ex-trade apprentices
under the Apprentices ... senior to the persons trained later. In
between the trained apprentices, preference shall be given
to those who are senior."
16. The Solicitor General
expressed the
desire that "other things being equal trained apprentices
should be given preference in case of employment".
10.For a promise ... senior to the persons trained
later. In between the trained apprentices,
preference shall be given to those who are
senior.
7
13.Insofar
India expressed the desire that
other things being equal trained apprentices should be given
preference in case of employment".
10. For a promise ... senior to the persons trained
later. In between the trained apprentices, preference shall
be given to those who are senior
apprentices governed by the Apprentices Act,
1961 . The relevant principles are as follows :
(i) Other things being equal, a trained apprentice should be given
preference ... treated senior to
the persons trained later. In between the trained apprentices, preference
shall be given to those who are senior".
In the said
other things being equal, the trained apprentices
should be given preference upon direct apprentices. This
judgment does not help the appellants at all. What ... that if the non-Railway trained apprentice is
equal to the Railways trained apprentice on merit, then
preference can be given to the Railways trained
apprentices governed by the Apprentices Act, 1961 . The relevant principles are as follows:
(i) Other things being equal, a trained apprentice should be given preference ... treated senior to the persons trained later. In between the trained apprentices, preference shall be given to those who are senior.
2. In the said
grounds. The defence of
the MCL was that the preference was given to the apprentices
who had undergone training with them in the interest ... Sangh and Others1 . It was submitted by
MCL that the preference to MCL apprentices was not influenced
by any consideration other than the interest
1998 was filed seeking
direction that the course completed Act Apprentices should
be given preference but the same was dismissed on 17.9.1998.
Ultimately merit list
with the Uttar Pradesh State
Electricity Board under the provisions of the Apprentices Act, 1961 . On completion of the period
of apprenticeship they claimed absorption ... apprentices, ignoring the age bar and giving them preference over candidates who were
not trained apprentices.
2. Here, it may be noted that a three
