after the competitive test, any apprentice trainee gets equal marks than a non-apprentice candidate, then only preference is to be given to the said ... interpreting the word ''preference' held that preference does not mean that the Railways trained apprentice will have an exclusive right
their
training:-
(1) Other things being equal, a trained apprentice
should be given preference over direct recruits.
(2) For this, a trainee would ... later. In between
1
AIR 1995 SC 1115
4
the trained apprentices, preference shall be
given to those who are senior".
6. Learned counsel
Supreme Court had held that the trained apprentices should be given
preference over the direct recruits. The relevant portion of the judgment reads
as follows ... senior to the
persons trained later. In between the trained
apprentices, preference shall be given to those who are
senior."
4.A similar view
given preference,
oe tet
. Sa 9. The analogy is not comprehensible as to why the matriculate CCAA, would
'be preferred over Graduate Apprentices when ... that of Matriculation and
Course Completed Act Apprentice Certificate and that Course Completed Act
Apprentices may get preference over others in the selection process
requisite criteria. Another order of this court 5 had directed grant of preference by
calling candidates who have undergone apprenticeship training in the Tamil Nadu ... viva-voce test. The preference was exercisable "when other things being
equal", over direct recruits. Consequently apprentice-trainees had no right
entitled to engage the
service of apprentices. Therefore, the model Standing Order is
statutorily applicable and therefore apprentices engaged are
excluded from the coverage under ... Appellate Tribunal genuinely represented by the petitioner
mill. Hence, the apprentices are not workers/ employees within the
Page
enrolled
employees, who were shown as apprentices. Aggrieved over the same, the
establishment preferred an appeal in ATA No.554 (13) 2011 before the first ... apprentices, photos of
training hall and class conducting session for the apprentices both theoretical
and practical, Names of the training officers, supervisors, list of apprentices
well settled that
other things being equal, a trained apprentice should be given
preference over direct recruits and for that a trainee would ... therefore the subsequent letter dated
12.11.1979 reserving 50 per cent vacancies for apprentice
trainees were not bad. Indeed the Government in its letter
dated
India, to
issue a Writ of Mandamus directing the respondents to give preferences
in filling up the vacancy of Wireman in the respondents Corporation ... Wireman in TANGEDCO. He underwent apprenticeship
training under the Apprentices Act, 1961 and therefore, preference is to
be given to the petitioner.
3.All appointments
apprentices to go through the process of viva-voce. This Court
has specifically laid down that a trained apprentice should be
given preference-other things ... recruits
and also clearly laid down the apprentice-trainees have no right
to be appointed in preference to other applicants.
10. I respectfully submit that
