principle that has to be followed in the matter of giving preference to apprentice trainees, is laid down in the following manner ... treated senior to the persons trained later. In between the trained apprentices, preference shall be given to those who are senior."
7. A perusal
after the competitive test, any apprentice trainee gets equal marks than a non-apprentice candidate, then only preference is to be given to the said ... interpreting the word ''preference' held that preference does not mean that the Railways trained apprentice will have an exclusive right
senior to the persons trained later. In between the trained apprentices, preference shall be given to those who are senior."
5. A question ... after the competitive test, any apprentice trainee gets equal marks than a non-apprentice candidate, then only preference is to be given to the said
trained apprentices giving the preference, ignoring the age bar and giving them preference over the candidates who are not trained apprentices.
4. When the matter ... different procedure for apprentice trainees only. The apprentice trainees would, at the best, after competing in examinations, be entitled to the preference to the extent
their training--
(1) Other things being equal, a trained apprentice should be given preference over direct recruit.
(2) For this, a trainee would ... senior to the persons trained later. In between the trained apprentices, preference shall be given to those who are senior.
13. Insofar as the cases
expressed the desire that "other things being equal trained apprentices should be given preference in case of employment."
9. Now on the basis ... senior to the
persons trained later- in between the trained apprentices, preference shall be given to those who are senior
granting preference to the appellants in the vacancies offered. The appellants also sought a direction to the respondents to give a preference to apprentice trainees ... after the competitive test, any apprentice trainee gets equal marks than a non-apprentice candidate, then only preference is to be given to the said
reproduced below: -
(i) Other things being equal, a trained apprentice should be given preference over direct recruits.
(ii) For this, a trainee would be required ... treated senior to the persons trained later. In between the trained apprentice, preference shall be given to those who are senior.
6. This question again
following directions :
(i) other things being equal, a trained apprentice should be given preference over direct recruits,
(ii) for this, a trainee would ... senior to the persons trained later. In between the trained apprentices, preference shall be given to those who are senior."
4. In accordance with
respect to apprentices who had undergone apprenticeship training:
(i) Other things being equal, a trained apprentice should be given preference over direct recruits ... treated senior to the persons trained later. In between the trained apprentice, preference shall be given to those who are senior.
4. Based
