rule is silent on this aspect, relaxation for the period
when the apprentice had undergone training would be given. It was also stated
Digitally signed ... seniors to the persons trained
later and in between the trained apprentices, preference shall be given to seniors.
Learned Counsel for the respondents has further
which they were stated. In between the trained Ex-
Trade Apprentice of RFI, preference were to be given to those who were senior ... given preference and that between trained Ex-Trade Apprentices of RFI
preference were to be given to those,.who were senior and such seniority
Exchange and open
advertisement to be issued inviting apf5lications.
iL Ex-Tradé apprentices need not apply and ex-trade 1apprentices of
the factory need ... practical test marks,
If marks are equal, ex-trade apprentices will be given preference.
Between ex-trade apprentices, candidates senior in balh will be
preferred
issued inviting applidations.
IL Ex-Trade apprentices need not apply and ex-trade apprentices of
the factory need not apply and they will be considered ... practical test marks.
X. If marks are equal, ex-trade apprentices will be given preference.
xL• Between dx-trade apprentices, candidates senior in batch will
hings.„beiffg equals trained apprentices
■•.V. ''
shall be given preference". The respondents wbuld arigue that "other
...y
V*.- T
things being ... after such examination, if an apprentice trainee gets equal marks
as that of a non-apprentice trainee, preference would be given to
)
the said apprentice
open advertisements whereby the
external candidates are given preference over the factory trained
own trade apprentices.
Let the Respondent authorities being restrained from giving
appointment ... vide Circular No. 520/All
dated 14.05.06 that cc-trade apprentices should be given
preference in recruitment in pursuance of the directives
given preference,
oe tet
. Sa 9. The analogy is not comprehensible as to why the matriculate CCAA, would
'be preferred over Graduate Apprentices when ... that of Matriculation and
Course Completed Act Apprentice Certificate and that Course Completed Act
Apprentices may get preference over others in the selection process
Annexure P5 to WP 7251
(W) of 2009]. He, however, preferred a representation on
3.1.2008 staking his claim to S-4 grade.
(viii) While disposing ... trade apprentices in non-works area Md^Khan havir^j poor
vision/ was not engaged Md*( Khan preferred a v;xlt petition be- ■
fore
dated 15-05- .
96 that ex-trade apprentices should be given preference in recruitment in
pursuance of the directives of Min. Of Labour which were ... batch.
(v) The representations preferred by applicants, who admittedly joined
after 01.01.2004 but out of the same apprentice list where the 15 60
figured
find that it has clearly been mentioned that the
Apprenticeship Training under Apprentice Act is not for employment in
Railway Establishment. However, as per PCPO ... direct recruitment in Level -
I shall be filled giving preference to the Course Completed Act
Apprentices trained in Railway Establishment and possessing National
Apprenticeship Certificate
