court, under Article 74(2) & Art 163(3) respectively, Article 163(3) Constitution
says:
The question whether any, and if so what, advice ... advice given to LG as available under Article
74(2) (regarding President) and Article 163(3) (regarding Governors). More over Article
163(3) applies specifically
Business
made under these two articles, viz., Article 77(3) in
the case of the President and Article 166(3) in the
case ... officers subordinate. The provisions
contained in Article 74 in the case of the President
and Article 163 in the case of the governor that
there
that it was protected against disclosure
both under Clause (3) of Article 163 and Section 123 of the
Indian Evidence Act, We are at present ... protection under Clause (3) of Article 183
because that is an Article which corresponds to Clause (2) of
Article 74 in so far as advice
relatable to the provisions contained in Article 53 in the case of the President and Article 154 in the case of the Governor, that ... officers subordinate. The provisions contained in Article 74 in the case of the President and Article 163 in the case of the Governor that there
Yatendra Singh Jafa vs Union Of India (Uoi) And Ors. on 29 July, 2003
Equivalent
relatable to the provisions contained in Article 53 in the case of the President and Article 154 in the case of the Governor, that ... officers subordinate. The provisions contained in Article 74 in the case of the President and Article 163 in the case of the Governor that there
relatable to the provisions contained in Article 53 in the case of the President and Article 154 in the case of the Governor, that ... officers subordinate. The provisions contained in Article 74 in the case of the President and Article 163 in the case of the Governor that there
name of the Governor as required by Article 166 of the Constitution. He submitted that in Article 166 of the Constitution of India ... Commissioner of Customs (Preventive), Mumbai. He submitted that under Articles 163(1) and 166(1) of the Constitution of India the advice of Council
relatable to the provisions contained in Article 53 in the case of the President and Article 154 in the case of the Governor, that ... officers subordinate. The provisions contained in Article 74 in the case of the President and Article 163 in the case of the Governor that there
framed in such a manner that the mandatory
provisions of Article 154 , Article 163 and Article 166 of the Constitution
are fulfilled. Therefore ... Constitutional responsibility of the
Chief Minister on advising the Governor under Article 163. "
Consequently, the Supreme Court declined to accept the contention
