Money
Bill.”
32) It is also useful to refer Article 212 which reads as under:
“212 - Courts not to inquire into proceedings of the Legislature ... ground that it offends Articles 197
to 199 and the procedure laid down in Article 202; (ii) Article 212
prohibits the validity of any proceedings
Money
Bill."
32) It is also useful to refer Article 212 which reads as under:
"212 - Courts not to inquire into proceedings ... ground
that it offends Articles 197 to 199 and the procedure laid down in
Article 202; (ii) Article 212 prohibits the validity of any
proceedings
meaning
of article 122 or, as the case may be, proceedings in the
Legislature of a State within the meaning of article 212.
1. Finding ... paragraph 2 of paragraph 6 to Tenth
Schedule read with Article 212(1) of the Constitution and purported to
apply what was stated
functioning. The Division Bench of this Court, with
reference to Articles 122 and 212 of the Constitution of India inter alia to
the effect that ... collateral purpose, as it would lead to conflict; (l) that Article 212 of the
Constitution of India also prohibits the validity of any proceedings
petitioner before this Court as PIL. It is submitted
that under Article 212 of the Constitution of India, the proceedings
of the Assembly cannot ... questioned by any person. Article 212 of
the Constitution of India, reads thus :
"212. Courts not to inquire into
proceedings of the Legislature
paragraph
6 (2) and (7) of the Tenth Schedule read with Article 212 of the
Constitution of India.
Mr. Kishore leading the arguments questioned ... paragraph 6(2) and 7 of the Tenth
Schedule read with Article 212 of the Constitution. It was thus
submitted that the writ petition
further submits that the jurisdiction of the Courts
is barred under Article 212 as well as paras 6(2) and 7 of the Tenth Schedule ... been initiated till date against the
petitioner.
Further, the bar of Article 212 of the Constitution is also prima facie
not attracted as this Court
Eighty-
Fifth Constitutional Amendment, Article 16 (4A) was added in the
Constitution of India, which provided that nothing in this Article shall
MANOJ KUMAR ... 212, that is, to first collect quantifiable
data in order to justify reservation in promotion for members of
the Scheduled Caste read with Article
been decided by any definitive
pronouncement of the Honble Supreme Court under Article 141
of the Constitution of India, guidance is available in the form ... gained constitutional
recognition in the form of Article 141 of the Constitution of India.
In fact, Section 212 of the Government of India
renewal is
declined, adhering to the same stand would be contrary to
Article 14 of the Constitution of India. It was submitted that ... others , (1991) 1 SCC 212, for
the proposition that applicability of Article 14 to all executive
actions of the State being settled
