Smt. Anandavally.M.K vs Dr. P.G.Jairaj on 14 March, 2011
IN THE
Legislature to enact legislation is contained in Article 245 of the
Constitution. Parliament has, by Article 246(1) , exclusive power
to make laws with respect ... under clauses 1 and
3 respectively of Article 246. The power conferred upon
Parliament by Article 246(1) is notwithstanding anything
contained in clauses
Seventh Schedule. By virtue of the non obstante clause contained in Article 246(1) of the Constitution, Parliament has exclusive power to make laws with ... contained in clauses (2) and (3) of Article 246. The non obstante clause under Article 246(1) indicates the predominance or supremacy
contained in clauses (2)
and (3) of Article 246. The non obstante clause under
Article 246(1) indicates the predominance or
supremacy ... first, by virtue of the non
obstante clause in Article 246(1) , in the second, by
reason of Article 254(1). Clause (2) of Article
1. `Acquisition and requisitioning of property' is relatable only to Entry 42 of
the Concurrent List (List III) of Schedule VII, read with Article ... 246 of the
Constitution of India. This, being a `stand alone entry', cannot be
incidental to any other law. The State has legislative competence
NDMC with
respect to the towers. Attention is also invited to Article 239 AA (3)(a)
whereunder the Legislative Assembly has been empowered to make ... laws, even if concerning/applicable to other facets would not apply.
Article 246(1) r/w Entry 31 in List I of the Seventh Schedule
what is the method of resolving the same.
47. Under Article 246(2) of the Constitution, the Legislature of a State
has the power ... List
III (concurrent list) in the Seventh Schedule, subject to Article 246(1). Under
Clause (3), the Legislature of a State has the exclusive power
legislation. The power to
legislate flows, amongst others, from Article
246 of the Constitution. Article 246(2) ,
being the source of power incorporates ... legislate in terms of Article 246
of the Constitution. While the States would
have exclusive power to legislate under
Article 246(2) of the Constitution
exclusive power to
levy a tax on services under article 246(1) read with Entry 92C of
List I of the VIIth Schedule ... Centre and the States. This mutual
exclusivity is reflected in Article 246(1) and has been noted
in H.M. Seervai's Constitutional
other substantial offences. In respect to the statutory enactments, Article 246 (1) of the Constitution provides that the Parliament has exclusive power to make laws ... subjects mentioned in List II in the Seventh Schedule subject to Article 246 (1) and (2). Article 246 (2) provides that notwithstanding anything in Clause