06th August, 2020 and 11th August, 2020. However, based on
the available APARs of the petitioner, the Screening Committee did not find
the petitioner ... based on the available
APARs/ACRs and submitted its report
with recommendation, wherein, Smt.
Dudeja has been screened out for all the
aforesaid years
Reports (APARs) upto the year
2007-2008 were to be reckonable. Since he actually joined only on
23.04.2007, only one APAR was available; thus ... APARs for
inclusion in USSL-2009. The same was the case for USSL-2010 since by
then only 2 APARs was available. Subsequently
availability of APARs. The same
reads as under:-
"It has been noticed that sometimes while
conducting selections some APARs are not
available ... award average marks for non-available APARs as out of
the fifth APARs, first year APAR was not available to him
as he was under
fact that the
reason given by DoPT i.e. non-availability of APAR Dossier is
incorrect whereas the applicant's APAR Dossier was delivered ... APAR.
F. The Respondent has given a misleading statement before the
Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) dated. 04.12.2020
that "APAR NOT AVAILABLE" whereas
APARs at a future date is against the methodology of the DPC. On the other hand, we find that the applicant has APARS available ... availability of APARs in future; in the second place, the applicant being a senior person, was having his APARs available, but it is not known
holding review DPC and assess
his suitability on the basis of available APARs and
promote him to the post of Superintendent of
Central Excise ... promotion as
Superintendent of Central Excise (GST) on the
basis of available APARs and grant him promotion
on the basis of suitability as adjudged
work, sense of responsibility etc. over
and above the available Annual Performance Appraisal Reports (APARs for
short) recommended the name of the petitioner for promotion ... work, sense of responsibility etc. over
9
and above the available APARs and recommended the name of the
petitioner for promotion to the post
Date:05.09.2022
12:21:36
Total 58.5‖
13. Turning then to the APARs, the respondents have noted the
following rating which was awarded ... Gupta, the respondent had
provided only four out of the 11 available APARs. Paritosh Sharma, on the
other hand, contends that only four
along with marks for
APARs by the Selection Committee. APARs for last 4 years will be
considered. Weightage of each APAR will ... under:
Professional/Managerial APAR Total
ability
(written test)
60 40 100
If APAR for 4 years are not available then marks will be awarded
which the reason stated by the respondents is that
APARs were not available since the petitioner joined service
only in 2007. As per Rule ... counted for USSL-2009 since only one APAR was available for
assessment by that time, however, he was then included in
USSL-2011 overlooking
