Majority Award and the third Arbitrator has passed the dissenting
Minority Award.
2. OMP No.410/2015 has been filed by M/s. Saisudhir Energy ... passed the said direction. By the said petition, the minority
Award has also been challenged as a whole.
3. NTPC Vidyut Vyapar Nigam Ltd. (hereinafter
Majority Award and the third Arbitrator has passed the dissenting
Minority Award.
2. OMP No.410/2015 has been filed by M/s. Saisudhir Energy ... passed the said direction. By the said petition, the minority
Award has also been challenged as a whole.
3. NTPC Vidyut Vyapar Nigam Ltd. (hereinafter
Additional Additional
No. the Claim Costs Costs Costs
Awarded by Awarded by
Majority in Minority in
Lac Rupees Lac Rupees
1. Additional Overhead Costs ... Additional Additional
No. the Claim Costs Costs Costs
Awarded by Awarded by
Majority in Minority in
Lac Rupees Lac Rupees
1. Additional Overhead Costs
rate
fixed under the contract. There is a minority award in favour of the
owner rejecting the claim laid.
5. Vide impugned order dated March ... majority award has noted that certain additional
works were awarded beyond the contract stipulated date and this has not
been noted by the minority arbitrator
there is only one award and that is the impugned award.
This Court makes it clear that the impugned award has been made ... entirety of the impugned award but only some parts of the
impugned award). There is a 'minority view' and a 'majority view
This was the majority decision but at the
same time, the minority award was passed by Mr. Madan
Mohan Sangal, the Appointee Arbitrator ... Contractor.
In such minority award, some of the claims of the
respondent were also partly allowed but the minority award
was never been the subject
From the above, it becomes clear that the applicant was awarded minor penalty, as provided under Rule 11 (i) to (iv) of CCS (CCA) Rules ... procedure for awarding minor penalty is prescribed under Rule 16 of CCS (CCA) Rules, the relevant portion which is quoted below: -
Rule 16. Procedure
Besides the aforesaid amount, the two minor
children were awarded 1,00,000/- each towards loss of love and
affection and the wife was awarded ... Transport Corporation (2015 (3) SCC
590), the Apex Court awarded 1,00,000/- each to minor
children/50,000/- each to the parents
participated in the enquiry. Out of the seven Managers, three were awarded minor punishment without holding enquiry against them and remaining two were left unquestioned ... isolated and ill treated by subjecting him to disciplinary proceedings and by awarding capital punishment for unexplained reasons. At any rate, imposing the capital punishment
petitioner was promoted on 14.01.2014 by taking into consideration
the earlier minor punishments awarded to him, thereafter, the same
cannot be made the basis again ... petition of the petitioner had taken in to
consideration only the minor punishments awarded to the petitioner, as
borne out from meeting note held
