wherein she had been graded 'Good', a grade
which was below the prescribed benchmark of 'Very Good'. Since there
were vacancies ... concerned for his response.
Opining that the effect of a below benchmark grading was prejudicial to
the interest of the appraise, inasmuch as right
down grading recorded by the Reviewing Officer gives no reasons thereof, such down graded grading should be ignored and the gradings assigned by the Reporting ... should be considered as adverse remark/grading. If the grading given to an officer is Good and the benchmark is Very Good (this
periods in
question which were below benchmark have been directed to be ignored
because below benchmark ACR gradings were never conveyed to the
respondent ... concerned for his response.
Opining that the effect of a below benchmark grading was prejudicial to the
interest of the appraise, inasmuch as right
impugns the OM dated 25.08.2010 rejecting his representation against the below benchmark grading in his ACR/APAR for 2006-07 (1.8.2006 to 31.3.2007) and year ... period from 1.8.2006 to 31.3.2007 and 01.04.2007 to 30.8.2007 having below benchmark grading as Average vide Ministrys OM No.12011/4/2008
Full Bench of this Tribunal in the same OA that below benchmark grading should be communicated to the officer reported upon, the DB considered ... Good gradings for the years 2003-04 and 2002-03 have not been communicated to the Applicant. These gradings, being below benchmark, would be considered
taken into consideration the adverse remarks and below benchmark grading Good in his ACR for the year 2003-04, against which the applicant had made ... support of his right to make a representation against the below benchmark grading in his ACR for the year 2003-04, the applicant has relied
years 1998-99 and 1999-2000 he was given the below benchmark grading and the Reporting and the Reviewing Officers were Mr. James Thomas, Joint ... authority, the overall grading in the ACR have to be kept blank for appropriate re-grading by the DPCs. The existing grading shall be blocked
higher grade in the employees service and (b) in case the Reviewing / Accepting Authority has down graded the grading given by the Reporting Authority ... ratio that any grading which has adverse civil consequences for an employee should be considered as adverse remark/grading. If the grading given
benefit of 1st MACP, solely on account of the below-benchmark grading in
his APAR for 2016-2017; that such APAR is vitiated ... graded "Average" and for 2017-2018 "Good" and that both
gradings were below the benchmark of "Very Good" required
were duly upgraded from Below Benchmark to Above
Benchmark grading, the Review DPC should have been constituted to
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:JYOTIRMOY ... assessed as 'Unfit‟ for
not meeting the required benchmark grade of „Very Good‟ due to his
confidential record of service
