graded below benchmark. Whereafter, based on the directions contained in OM dated 13.04.2010, the below benchmark grading was communicated to the respondent ... below benchmark ACR gradig in Competent Authority and since there were no grounds for upgradation of below benchmark grading of ACR for the period
graded
'Good'. He was graded 'Good', which is classified suitable for next
promotion, thus it cannot be viewed that the grading ... benchmark with the suitable grading in the ACR, yet in the
19
subsequent year when given grading falling short of benchmark is
certainly an impediment
Scheme based
MANISH KUMAR
SRIVASTAVA
7
on the required benchmark grading, indicating eligibility for career
progression under this scheme. Learned counsel for the respondents
further ... gradings since 1.9.2008.
Applicant No. 2 had mostly 'Average', or 'Good' gradings, with only
one 'Very Good' grading since
ignoring such of those ACRs containing the below benchmark
grading which were not communicated and which, therefore could not have
been taken into account while ... year
2006 2007 is "Average" which is Below the Benchmark grading of "Good".
2006-2007
Since this ACRs was reckoned
against the vacancies of 2006-2008 by ignoring the below benchmark grading contained in the ACR for the period 2004-05 with all consequential benefits ... which he could not be given regular promotion. The below benchmark grading had been communicated to him vide the above order for his representation (Annexure
substance of these judgments are that in
the event of below benchmark grading or/and adverse
remarks found in the APAR for the relevant period ... promotion,
if such adverse remarks or below benchmark grading are
subsequently upgraded/expunged by the competent
authority, its effect on the career prospects
promotion to the said grade was due to below Benchmark
grading in his APAR from 01.04.2012 to 31.03.2013 [2012-13].
RAVI KUMAR ... four
Benchmark grading, out of five ACARs gradings, should be
assessed fit for the post of Superintending Geologist. Accordingly,
notwithstanding the below Benchmark grading
grading for 2006-07 was "Good", and the
gradings for 2007-08 and 2008-09 were "Very Good". Since
the benchmark ... establish entitlement to another higher grade,
particularly when the higher grade requires separate screening and
fulfilment of the prescribed benchmark for the relevant period
expunge the adverse remarks and below
benchmark grade in the impugned APARs
for both the relevant periods from ... relevant period agreed with
the aforesaid adverse remarks and below benchmark
grade entered by the Reporting Officer without exercising
any independent thought and submitted
seven years in Selection Grade for
promotion to Sr. Administrative Grade. As the applicant was
promoted to Selection Grade with effect from 24.01.2008 the
residency ... 00332/2011
promotion to Selection Grade,
Grade, without sharing the below
benchmark grading , was in accordance with the law prevailing
at that time.
(b) Whether
