pass in
equivalent examination, so also Degree in Carnatic Music from a
recognized University. In the alternative, applicants with pass in
Ganabhooshanam/Ganapraveena or certificate ... passed examination in
Ganabhooshanam with the core subject Violin and not Carnatic
Vocal. The main contention of fourth respondent/writ petitioner is,
the present appellant
Labour Appellate Tribunal as early as 1951 in Buckingham and Carnatic Company, Ltd. v. Their Workmen 1951 II L.L.J. 314 and since then ... consistently followed by Industrial Tribunals and we think rightly. Vide Buckingham and Carnatic Company Ltd. v. Worker of the Company
stated that since the 4th respondent
does not have a qualification in Carnatic music, the 4th respondent
is ineligible for the post, and therefore ... notification, the educational
qualification prescribed is Degree in Carnatic
WPC No. 31401/09
:4 :
Music/Ganabhooshanam or Ganapraveena. Therefore, the
qualification which a candidate
para 3, in Assistant Commissioner, Urban Land Tax, Madras v. Buckingham and Carnatic Co. Ltd. , AIR 1970 SC 169 para 11 and again
under common law, as held by the Supreme Court in Buckingham & Carnatic Co. Ltd. v. Venkatiah (1963-I-LLJ-638) an inference that
Dutt and Co. v. Its Workmen , Buckingham and Carnatic Co. v. Venkatiah , and Murugan Mills Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal ... issue before the Calcutta High Court. The point decided in Buckingham and Carnatic Co. v. Venkatiah , has again no relevance to the contention before
public. The rationale of the decision in Vajrapani Naidu v. New Theatres Carnatic Talkies Ltd. , (AIR 1964 SC 1440), strongly pressed to sustain the principle
said in Assistant Commissioner of Urban Land Tax, Madras v. Buckingham and Carnatic ... case in Assistant Commissioner of Urban Land Tax, Madras v. Buckingham and Carnatic Co. , the Supreme Court was concerned with the validity of the Madras
witnesses.
7. In the case of Workmen in Buckingham and Carnatic Mills, Madras v. Buckingham and Carnatic Mills Ltd., Madras
failure to appoint a Presenting Officer. In Workmen of Buckingham and Carnatic Mills v. Buckingham and Carnatic Mills, Madras, (1970-I-LLJ-26 ), the Supreme
